Pick 1 ROS

[1320kid]

H2H points, 4W -2GA .2SV and 1 for OTL. Would you rather have Gibby, Hart, Flower, or Oettinger?

[Feenom]

Flower - not in Chicago

Hart - No

It's between Ott and Gibby for me. I will hope that the Ducks continue playing well, if they don't play well it won't be Gibby's fault, he's a beast. So Gibson, Ott, Hart/Fleury. Good luck.

[senryu]

I agree that it is between Gibson and Oettinger. Because Gibson is the unquestioned starter and wins are rather valuable in your system, I'd go with the guy most likely to reap the most wins, which is Gibson. If Holtby crapped out and Dallas made the right move and put Oettinger in at least 60% of the time, then it'd be Oettinger.

[1320kid]

Thanks guys. I kind of figured the same...it is a question of a bona fide starter on a historically inconsistent team vs timeshare on a better team. I agree if Ott was the clear #1 I'd roll him.

[tweetdrivr]

Yeah I’d go Gibson here for this season.

[captaincrunch32]

late to the game here but after having Gibson last year..he started out well and then wore down. This year, the team playing in front of him is a little more solid that the team in front of him last year but I'd rather take Ott and the better team in Dallas.

[Axeman33]

Gibson

[iglooinhabitant]

I'm stunned people think Oettinger beats Fleury and Hart for rest of this season. I'd take either over him without question (since Holtby should play over 50% of remaining games).

Gibson
Fleury/Hart (tough call between these 2. Fleury is a better goalie today but Chicago is probably worse than Philly.)
Oettinger

For this season.

[Wonko]

My order:

Fleury/Hartt
Gibson
Oettinger

[senryu]

I'm stunned people think Oettinger beats Fleury and Hart for rest of this season. I'd take either over him without question (since Holtby should play over 50% of remaining games).

Gibson
Fleury/Hart (tough call between these 2. Fleury is a better goalie today but Chicago is probably worse than Philly.)
Oettinger

For this season.

Well, Hart and Oettinger have the same number of NHL wins, with Oettinger having spent half the season in the AHL and the other half as a semi-backup. If Fleury is traded to a contending team and given a 1 or 1A role, then Fleury makes sense, but I'd think the odds of Oettinger taking the job in Dallas from Braden Holtby is greater than the Fleury to a team like Colorado scenario.

[stevegamer]

Gibson - Playing well, and having Stolarz instead of Miller will help keep Gibson much fresher.
Oettinger - He should be up for the rest of the year, and he's been very good.
Hart - Flyers have issues, and it starts with the GM. Getting Ellis back will help, if they can get Yandle out of the lineup.
Fleury - assuming no trade, or a trade to a team where he's not instantly the starter on a great team.

[tweetdrivr]

Yeah that’s it.