Barrie + vs Chychrun+

[Henrik18]

Hey there,

I got an offer in my dynasty league, and don't know what to think about it:

My Barrie + Bunting for his Chychrun + Rakell

What do you think about Chychrun? i mean he had a pretty good season last year, and if he can put his sh** toigether he could be a pretty valuable player in my league?

Barrie doesn't have much value when he doresn't score...he doesn't offer peripherals... and if Bouchard take over PP1 duties...that's it for Barrie i guess?

Also what do you guys think of Bunting?is he legit, or will he fall off at some point?

Curious what your thoughts are...thanks guys

rep whenever i can

Team and league in sig.

[Henrik18]

I mean Barrie is 30...Chychrun is 23

Chychrun isn't in his prime yet...how many good years if he doesn't lose PP1 does Barrie have left?


What if i counter with Crouse instead of Bunting?

[Belexus75]

i rather give up Crouse..Chychrun been struggling but i dont think its him, its the team...for long term i think he is best player in this deal...for this year and probably next i prefer Barrie side

[Henrik18]

thank you for your opinion...but would you do that deal now?

I mean probably i don't have the chance to get Chychrun in 1 or 2 years for Barrie?

Crouse for Rakell also good?

[Henrik18]

He wants Bunting + Barrie?

Should i accept or hold?

I know Barrie will outscore Chychrun... but when he doesn't score he's got no value?

Don't know what to do

[Belexus75]

again depending on the set up and yoru situation...

as i said, if you are in win now mode you keep what you got...if you building for future i like this....

Bunting is a wild card, to me he is improving with every game i can see consistent 50 points in years to come.

but im not gonna tell you what to do, thats up to you

[Henrik18]

I'm currently 4th out of 16 teams, but personally i don't think i have a chance to win it this year.

I know Bunting is a wildcard, but i also had the same thoughts of him like you said.

Yah, i know it's up to me...but anyways thank you for your help

[stevegamer]

I think I'd do it, as long as you are willing to accept punting +/-. That's why Chychrun is so terrible this year, plus they got an actual PP QB.

[Henrik18]

+/- isn‘t the big problem for me!

You think Chychrun will get PP Duties back?

What i want to say is,why would you do it when there is an other PP- QB and his +/- is terrible?
What‘s the big plus?just his age?

[stevegamer]

+/- isn‘t the big problem for me!

You think Chychrun will get PP Duties back?

What i want to say is,why would you do it when there is an other PP- QB and his +/- is terrible?
What‘s the big plus?just his age?

Right now Arizona is using 2D on PP1, so he has PP1 duties back. To be honest, getting Gostisbehere was a great deal for Arizona at the cost of absolutely nothing - possibly the steal of the year, but then again Fletcher is a stupid GM.

Barrie is all offense, and he's not the best offensive D in Edmonton, that would be Bouchard. Bouchard is already outscoring him, and while Barrie will get his points, he's not the clear sole PP1 QB.

Bunting might be as legit as Rakell is, or he may not be. So I'd grab the more certain forward, and the better dynasty D.

[Henrik18]

Thanks
Absolutly makes sense!
I will do it