Need help picking a goalie

[fudgecamel]

I am in a pickle and don't know which goaltender to get rid of. Nobody is trading in this league.
I have Demko, Talbot, Koskinen and Blackwood.
The categories are Wins and SV%.

I'm thinking Koski gets less starts when smith is back but the team doesn't stop winning.. whereas Demko is a better goalie and the definite starter over in VAN but the team seems very weak defensively this year. I like Blackwood's numbers so far and Talbot seems like an easy keep for me.

Any insight is appreciated, thank you.

[Swels Stewart]

What is your league size and which other goalies are FA right now? Do you NEED to drop one in the short-term?

[fudgecamel]

12 team league, 10 category H2H. Only two goalie cats so 4 goalies is overkill. Most GMs have 2, some have 3. One guy has none. Waiver guys available right now would be like Greiss, Reimer, Jones, Petersen, Nedelkovic. I would rather have another forward/def than have 4 goalies with only two starting slots per night.

[random-d]

Keep Talbot and Koskinen (Demko as well if you want a spot starter). Go with the goalies that get the volume of starts. Worry about Smith when you have to, you could always pick up Petersen when that time comes or stream options from WW.

[Invictus]

12 team league, 10 category H2H. Only two goalie cats so 4 goalies is overkill. Most GMs have 2, some have 3. One guy has none. Waiver guys available right now would be like Greiss, Reimer, Jones, Petersen, Nedelkovic. I would rather have another forward/def than have 4 goalies with only two starting slots per night.

More than likely you are losing forward GP's by having 4 goalies. See if this is true. If so, I'd probably be dropping Demko.