2 Offers to Think About

[jager19]

10 team 5 Keeper Roto league with G,A,+/-,PIM,PPP,SOG,FW and W,SO,GAA,SV% for stats....Here is my team:

C-E.Malkin, E.Staal
LW-B.Morrow, Si.Gagne
RW-M.Hossa, S.Doan
F-S.Gomez
D-B.Rafalski,A.Markov, K.Timonen, K.Bieksa
Ben-D.Brown, J.Sakic, S.Zubov
IR-R.Whitney
G-R.Luongo, R.Miller
Ben-I.Bryzgalov

I have been offered 2 trades...please give me some assitance

Offer 1
I get:
E.Nabokov
H.Zetterberg
M.Savard

He gets:
R.Luongo
Si.Gagne
E.Staal
S.Gomez

Offer 2
I get:
E.Nabokov
H.Zetterberg
M.Gerber (if I want) I\'d rather pick Halak as a free agent

He gets:
R.Luongo
I.Bryzgalov
Si.Gagne

SHOULD I MAKE ONE OF THESE TRADES? OR AM I BETTER NOT MAKING EITHER????

[jager19]

Giving KARMA for best responses.....

[newper114]

i dont like either of these trades for you.

Offer 1
I get:
E.Nabokov = R.Luongo
H.Zetterberg = E.Staal (give or take some points)
M.Savard lose 2 great goalies to bring one back in. zett is a huge plus but you got enough already.

EDIT: i dont know my whole message isnt posting and this doesnt make sense. bottom line dont like either trade for you.

[JHM]

The common thread is that you give up

Luongo
S. Gagner

and receive

Nabokov
Zetterberg

I wonder after reviewing the offers if I\'d send that back to him, in the event I decided I was interested.

Luongo is the best player in the deal.

Nabokov led all NHL tenders (all players in many leagues) in scoring last year
Age factor and health factor go to Luongo.

Zetterberg crushes Gagner. He\'s a top 5 LW (more like top 3). Elite. Back issues are the biggest concern.

Gagner. Talk about health issues. He\'s one hit from retired at this point. In top form, he\'s point a game with over 40 goals.

I think I\'d be taking the Nabokov/Zetterberg arrangement then. Two super elites for one diversifies your assets. I don\'t like Gagner. He\'s been too disappointing too many times. I\'d probably keep my nose to the grindstone and see that I couldn\'t get my injury risk factor improved with another trade or two. Heatley, Iggy, Kane, Kovy, Hossa would be some of the names on my shopping list. Maybe Crosby, Malkin, Ovy. I love Zetterberg, but he too promises to disappoint.

I like what Bryz represents right now. I wouldn\'t really want to be trading him.

Gerber.... injured, bothersome, insecure piece that you can\'t trade.

Staal is a significantly younger Savard in many respects.

Gomez is quite veteran, and contributes his 70 points. Not a bad thing. The kind of thing I like to pick up on the cheap, given the chance.

If he\'s sent a pair of offers, if you\'re interested, why not counter? I think there\'s a pretty good chance that he would do the trade.

[oilerblue]

I\'d take the second offer.

Nabokov and Luongo are fairly close IMO, one has a better team the other is a better goalie.
Gerber is your back-up so who cares about him.
So basically it comes down to Zetterberg for Bryzgalov (current back-up) and Gagne...yes please!!!
Plus you potentially add 2 keepers in Zetterberg and Nabokov while giving up just one in Luongo.