Mantha vs Domi

[DDCRAVEN]

Points only, position doesn't matter, who do you like for this year and 3 years down the road?

[jeff_pro_mason]

That's an easy one. Mantha's the choice here, no doubt!

[tweetdrivr]

With what very limited info you've posted Mantha - if he can stay healthy. Domi has slighly better numbers but he hasn't missed many games. If they had played the same amount Mantha would be much better.

[lucafen4]

I'll take Mantha in 2 of the next 3 years.

I figure Domi will have one good year and then disappear the other two

[Palefa]

No matter how thing turn out, Domi always finish close or with more points than Mantha. But I still prefer Mantha on my team.

[lucafen4]

No matter how thing turn out, Domi always finish close or with more points than Mantha. But I still prefer Mantha on my team.

it just took an extra 21gp last year for Domi to match Mantha's 38pts

[stevegamer]

Mantha.

This is close only if Mantha gets hurt every year. If Domi ever gets hurt, it won't be close.

[tweetdrivr]

Mantha.

This is close only if Mantha gets hurt every year. If Domi ever gets hurt, it won't be close.

Or, hopefully, if Mantha stays healthy! The wings are now paying him like a guy who is.

[havanablast21]

I actually like Domi... really do. Maybe it's my connection to the Leafs and his Dad... but in this compare, I gotta give the edge overall to Mantha. I'm concerned about all the teams kicking Domi out the door... Galchenyuk style. Not sure what the issue is there. I really hope he finds his toe hold, maybe in Columbus, but Mantha is a leader in Detroit. He gets my vote.

[stevegamer]

Or, hopefully, if Mantha stays healthy! The wings are now paying him like a guy who is.

I agree, but honestly he only has to stay healthy one year to make this not very close.

[tweetdrivr]

I agree, but honestly he only has to stay healthy one year to make this not very close.

Yep!