Thoughts on this offer?

[bbfl1987]

I was offered DeBrusk, Gurianov, and a later pick which won’t get me much in the draft for my Cirelli and Merkley. There is a handshake agreement that he would send me Cirelli back for DeBrusk after a couple weeks. Tampa has a good sched coming up and he wants Cirelli for that time. So basically what I’m asking is Gurianov a better own than Merkley? I’m in a points only 12 team keeper league. Keep 9 any position.





Barzal
Konecny
Mantha
Meier
Karlsson
Duclair
Dvorak
Schmaltz
Cirelli
Thomas
Labanc
Roslovic










Hronek
Vatanen
Leddy
Girard
Myers




Lundqvist
Howard
Brossoit




(P) Hart
(P) Caufield
(P) Zegras
(P) Cozens
(P) Bouchard
(P) Merkley

[stevegamer]

I was offered DeBrusk, Gurianov, and a later pick which won’t get me much in the draft for my Cirelli and Merkley. There is a handshake agreement that he would send me Cirelli back for DeBrusk after a couple weeks. Tampa has a good sched coming up and he wants Cirelli for that time. So basically what I’m asking is Gurianov a better own than Merkley? I’m in a points only 12 team keeper league. Keep 9 any position.

The only thing that matters for me is the bolded. You and the other owner are colluding to gain him an advantage over the other teams in the league, due to the tradeback. If you do that part of the deal, you need to understand that there is a very high chance that the value you assign to the players won't matter, as you should (assuming a competent commissioner) both be ex-league members.

[bbfl1987]

It’s happened several times in the league I’m in. Nobody seems to have a problem with. I’m sorry you have a problem with it.

[stevegamer]

It’s happened several times in the league I’m in. Nobody seems to have a problem with. I’m sorry you have a problem with it.

No problem, if that's the way the league rolls, it's fine with you guys, and that's what matters. It's just really weird to see stuff like that going down; combining rosters often leads to issues..

[Gretzky99Orr4]

Which Merkley?