Would you take DeAngelo over Shattenkirk?

[1000er]

Points only league.

I've narrowed it down to these two names.

Shattenkirk or DeAngelo going forward? And why?

[Pengwin7]

DeAngelo is the D1 on the PP1 for NYR.
I don't think Shatty can hold that for TB.

[hockeyrobot]

DeAngelo is the D1 on the PP1 for NYR.
I don't think Shatty can hold that for TB.

Yep he nailed it. I like Deangelo.

[VincentVega]

Another vote for DeAngelo. Looking at the oiSH%, it doesn't look like he's been lucky this year so current production seems more or less sustainable.

Incidentally, Tony DeAngelo is the first Rangers defenseman who has recorded five goals in the team's first 13 games of a season since Brian Leetch in 1988-89

[lucafen4]

I called ADA over Shatty in another thread yesterday.

ADA just provided more reasons last night why I choose him.

(8m seems a lot to pay a Dman that doesn't provide any PP time... )

[1000er]

Thanks guys! really helpful

[Danivince]

I’m trying to figure out him or S.Theodore? Lol any thoughts?