Tough call....been offered E. Karlsson...

[Skeeps]

....for my Patty Kane.

Thoughts??

[MZac]

Super close. Even positionally on your team in signature there is no clear answer. D is deeper with 6 but you're strong there with a lot of depth (almost too much?) and you are also loaded on RW. When it's this close and if he came to you I'd want an add to pull the trigger.

[Rockies & Hockeys]

I'd do it. You're super strong on the wing, and Karlsson is a beauty. Also younger than Kane.

[ross10019]

I'd do it. It's 1.5 points for Dmen, and you will have Karlsson, Makar, Rielly, Josi and Letang on the back end, a D like that should win most leagues!!

[MZac]

I'd do it. It's 1.5 points for Dmen, and you will have Karlsson, Makar, Rielly, Josi and Letang on the back end, a D like that should win most leagues!!

Good catch. I missed 1.5 points for defensemen. This is enough for me to take him at your deepest league position.

[Rajin]

I'd keep Kane he's slightly more valuable than Karlsson, and your D is already good, so trading Kane will diminish your forward depth.

[ross10019]

I'd keep Kane he's slightly more valuable than Karlsson, and your D is already good, so trading Kane will diminish your forward depth.

This league is 1.5 points for dmen, 1 point for forwards.

So basically most years Karlsson will outpoint Kane in this league, AS A DEFENSEMAN.

So I have to disagree bud, I think in fact Karlsson is considerably more valuable than Karlsson in this league.

[Rajin]

Missed the fine print, would agree to Karlsson over Kane.

[Skeeps]

Missed the fine print, would agree to Karlsson over Kane.

Made the deal. But he wanted Girard. So I countered with him adding Pavelski. So it ended up being Joe P and Karl for my Patty and Girard. I took some risk, but huge possible reward.