semin bieksa / A.Kostytsin redden

[kopi11]

A guy is offering me Semin and Bieksa for A. Kostytsin and Redden is that too much i give?
Thanks for advice and have a nice day.

[woodrow]

You don\'t gain anything from this trade in my opinion. Semin and Kostitsyn seem to be about equal talents but Redden will outproduce Bieksa. I wouldn\'t do it.

[Narayan]

AK and Semin are pretty equal with Semin have injury problems in the past I might give the edge to AK

and I would prefer Redden over Bieska who seems to be another band aid boy


Moved to the appropriate forum as well.

[Shoeless]

Hmmm and please note that Redden is on Dobber\'s certified band-aid boy list already.