Need advice on this deal

[MasterX57]

Connor Tuch Goldobin Morrissey or Butcher
VS
My: Keller Tolvanen Necas Makar
dp included in the deal: he's getting a 1st pick and I'm getting a 3rd rounder.
I'll add infos 'bout league and team in a sec.

[MasterX57]

Forwards
1- P.Kane
2-Hall
3-Rantanen
4-Forsberg
5-Rakell
6-Keller
7-Ehlers
8-Duchene
9-Kaprizov
10-Pettersson
11-Dadonov
12-Tolvanen
13-Necas
14-N.Suzuki
15-Kapanen
16-Frost
17-Bellows
18-Hoffman
19-Sikura
20-Denisenko
21-Kupari
22-Iskhakov
23-Kravtsov
24-Patrick

D-Men
1-Klingberg
2-Chabot
3-Makar
4-Montour
5-Dahlin
6-Liljegren
7-Bean
8-Clague

Goalies
1-Jones
2-Samsonov
3-Demko

14 Forwards, 6 d-mens, 2 goalies counting
35 players
Goals and assists only for skaters
W 2pts T 1pt SO 5pts for goaltenders
No salary cap
10 teams