Matthews

[Henrik18]

Hey there!

Because of his history with injurys would you consider a trade Matthews for Pertersson?

Or Point+Chabot for Matthews?

So my question is...would you trade him?and if so,which trade would be better?

[als_revenge]

No, I wouldn't trade Matthews cuz he might get hurt. Heck, if you make this deal, would you then trade Pettersson because he might get another concussion?

[Sidenown]

If you can get Point ++ I would think about it. Point is not far off from Matthews (I do think Matthews is better), but if you can get Chabot and another piece maybe I would consider it. The injury doesn't really worry me, I just am high on Point and I think Matthews value in trades will always be a little higher than his (rightfully very high) actual value so if you can find a GM that is willing to give you a big overpay in such a deep keeper I would consider doing it, especially when you already have McDavid at centre.

- - - Updated - - -

Petersson trade is a hard no for me. Matthews is for sure the real deal, Pettersson hasn't shown enough yet to be the one piece in this trade. Need a lot more than that to move the needle for me.

[PenguinHunter]

In a Head to Head keeper league, no I would not trade him for either of these.

AS long as you have a IR spot then he is an asset to you. When he is injured you can stream guys that are hot.

H2H is largely about the players that will get you the most points per game. So keep him and hope that he is always healthy for when your league playoffs are.

[lucafen4]

If you can get Point ++ I would think about it. Point is not far off from Matthews (I do think Matthews is better), but if you can get Chabot and another piece maybe I would consider it. The injury doesn't really worry me, I just am high on Point and I think Matthews value in trades will always be a little higher than his (rightfully very high) actual value so if you can find a GM that is willing to give you a big overpay in such a deep keeper I would consider doing it, especially when you already have McDavid at centre.

- - - Updated - - -

Petersson trade is a hard no for me. Matthews is for sure the real deal, Pettersson hasn't shown enough yet to be the one piece in this trade. Need a lot more than that to move the needle for me.

I'm sitting close to this line of thinking. I would want another piece added to Point & Chabot for AM... & if you can get another piece added to Pettersson, I'd consider that as well.

unless - you league favours goal scoring, which it doesn't seem to.

As the deals are right now, I'm holding AM.

[Henrik18]

At first thanks for all your opinions

I like the Point-Chabot thing as well...thought about to ask for his 1st round pick and give my 3rd!

i think the 1st is very important in our league,we just have to drop 3 players
But it has to be 1 of our top 5 players-1 of the top 10 and 1 random player!

I think that would be a trade i would consider because i would be competitive this year and would have an extra 1st rounder?

Thoughts?

[Sidenown]

What other pieces does the Point/Chabot owner have on his roster? In a 10 team keeper, that means the first round made up of the 40-50th best players...which is good but might consider trying to get a piece that helps you now.

[Henrik18]

Forwards:
Pettersson/Elias Lindholm/ROR/Voracek/Will Karlsson/Kuznetsov/Zibanejad

Defense: Hedman/Gost

[lucafen4]

Pettersson & Chabot... I would go after