Rantanen vs Seguin

[am78]

In a points only pool for this Year. Who would you rather have? Seguin is obviously the safer pick and has alot of upside and I know the other team agrees

But I think I can get Letang and Rantanen for Seguin Werenski

[MasterX57]

Letang will probably get injured anyway and both Rantanen and Seguin have 90 points upside in my opinion. So all-in-all stick with Seguin and Werenski

[am78]

Letang will probably get injured anyway and both Rantanen and Seguin have 90 points upside in my opinion. So all-in-all stick with Seguin and Werenski

I do agree letang will get injured but we do have an IR plus slot and decent dmen to take fliers on If and when that does happen...what If i was also able to extract a draft pick?

[RevRath]

In a points only I'd make that deal. Letang is absolutely an upgrade from Werenski and without SOG Seguin and Rantanen are more similar. Certain duos are worth being on your roster together and I think in this case Mackinnon and Rantanen could be lights out for you.

[Axeman33]

I prefer Seguin to Rantanen but I also prefer Letang to Werenski so to me, this is pretty much a push. I don't see a reason to make this deal unless you just want to make a deal just so you can say you made a deal.

[Digested Chimichanga Head]

I'd pass on this offer. I'd rather have Seguin on my team then any of the players mentioned

[seguingenesis]

What kind of draft pick we talking about?

More importantly, what goalies does the other owner have?

[j0hn_d0e]

It's a close one, but I prefer Seguin Werenski side.

[am78]

What kind of draft pick we talking about?

More importantly, what goalies does the other owner have?

He has Murray and Dubnyk and we get 2 for a win and 3 more for a shutout NO SV% etc etc
And i think we can swap out a 3rd for 4th kinda move...nothing earth shattering

Also I grabbed Crawford and stashed him as another owner dropped him for some dumb reason. Still have Quick on IR and playing Crawford and Bishop and looking to trade Crawford

[MasterX57]

Not enough improvement in my opinion, keep what you have

[apollo18]

letang and rant take it just because letang has been getting tons of points due to healthy malk and kessel

[saucelife90]

I prefer Seguin to Rantanen but I also prefer Letang to Werenski so to me, this is pretty much a push. I don't see a reason to make this deal unless you just want to make a deal just so you can say you made a deal.

Pretty much this. If you can guarantee me Letang stays healthy and plays 75+ games, give me that side, however we all know the history he has so because of that risk I think it's a lateral move.