Trade Crosby for E Karlsson

[Phil Kessel, snacktime hero]

BLUF: Should I trade Crosby for Erik Karlsson?

First post, total new guy to the fantasy hockey world. Just joined a 10 team dynasty league that gives you 10 years in contracts to dole out. If this is the wrong place I apologize in advance.
I had the 3rd overall pick in rnd 1 and took Crosby. I potentially have the option to trade him for Erik Karlsson. Fair?

League details:
2 ea. C/RW/LW
1 Util
4 D
2 G
4 bench

My team is:
C: Crosby, W. Karlsson, O'Reilly (bench)
LW: Huberdeau, Hoffman
RW: Marner, Nylander
Util: Barzal, Hertl (bench)
D: Burns, J. Carlson, Sergachev, Pulock, Ekholm (bench)
G: Bobrovsy, Fleury, Hutton (bench)

Should I make the trade? I can fill Crosby's spot with Barzal or OReilly

[Joker]

I don't think you need to make this trade. Your D is solid and losing Crosby hurts you up front. The deal itself is fair, I just don't think you need it.

[Axeman33]

Welcome to the forums.

What is your league setup? Points only? Multicat? If multicat, what categories?

[Phil Kessel, snacktime hero]

I don't think you need to make this trade. Your D is solid and losing Crosby hurts you up front. The deal itself is fair, I just don't think you need it.

Makes sense. I think I was tempted bc I love Karlsson and don't love Crosby. I will probably pass on him. Plus the other guy needs front help, so i'm also denying him that. Thanks for the reply

[Phil Kessel, snacktime hero]

Welcome to the forums.

What is your league setup? Points only? Multicat? If multicat, what categories?

Thank you. Head to head, points only

[Axeman33]

Thank you. Head to head, points only

Thanks. I'd also keep Crisby.