Reply With Quoteedthebum wrote:
With positions requirement \"maybe\" !Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
thanks
Without NO !
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
thanks
15 teams, 1 NHL point=1 point, goalie win=2, shutout=3, PIM=0.2
Must have 10 forwards,4 Defensemen,1 Goalie active in line up from bench of 25. Line up set once a week. 6 keepers
My Team
Forwards: Ovechkin,Kovalchuk,Roy,Hossa,Zherdev,Huselius,Staj an,Upshall,Wheeler, Frolov,Horcoff,Lombardi,Andrei Kostitsyn,MacArthur,Hanzal
Defensemen:Goligoski,Whitney,Martin,McCabe,Robidas
Goalie:Rinne,Leighton
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
edthebum wrote:
With positions requirement \"maybe\" !Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
thanks
Without NO !
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
I agree with Pete. Need more info to really be able to assess. I would tend to keep Hossa over most anybody myself.
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
Just based on age, I\'d go for it. Getzlaf is a stud.
15 team keeper league, points only
3 C, 6 W, 4 D
core of 16, plus 3 rookies (**), 6 round annual draft
C - Thornton, M Richards, B Richards [McDonald, S. Koivu]
W - Ovechkin, Kovalchuk, Vanek, St. Louis, Whitney, Hemsky [Hartnell, Knuble, Lupul]
D - Gonchar, Visnovsky, Whitney, Kronwall [Kuba, Cumiskey]
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
You\'re in a keeper league.
If you have positional requirements
RW has about four or five guys that are in an elite group in the NHL. Hossa is clearly in that group. Despite the age difference there isn\'t a chance I\'d give up Hossa for Getzlaf. Calling Hossa the 5th best RW in the league, you would be trading him for the 15th best centre in the league. I wouldn\'t trade him for Joe Thornton, Vinny Lecavalier or Pavel Datsyuk either. (I\'m sure some disagree)
If you do not have positional requirements. I would entertain the trade. If I had Hossa I\'d clearly be asking for something to be thrown in. I might get laughed at, but that\'s all right. I could always downgrade to a 1-for-1 offer. It\'s important that you believe that Getzlaf is going to be awesome for a very long time and that you think he\'s going to start producing in that 90-100 point window. If you think that\'s a bit high, then have fun driving Hossa instead for the next five years. Age comparison between these two isn\'t all it\'s cracked up to be. If you believe Hossa is prime material for the next five years, the comparison is essentially irrelevant.
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
Well said as usual, JHM.
The only think I would add is that you should only entertain this idea IF PIM is counted in your league. That is one statistical category that Getzlaf has a clear advantage in.
That said, if your league has positional requirements I would forget the trade and keep Hossa regardless.
15 GM Keeper League w/Roto Scoring (G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, HITS | W, GAA, SV%, SHO)
Start 4 C, 4 LW, 4 RW, 6 D, 2 G (23-man rosters) | Protect 10 players w/a max of 1 goalie
C - Crosby*, Malkin* (C/R), Tavares*, Giroux* (C/R)
L - Duchene* (C/L), Marleau* (C/L), Galchenyuk (C/L), Ott (C/L), Lee (C/L)
R - Kane* (C/R), St. Louis, Neil, Clutterbuck
D - Yandle*, Carlson*, Gardiner, Gudas, Daley, Bieksa, Schenn
G - Lundqvist*, Rinne, Kuemper
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
rticinelli wrote:
bingo.Well said as usual, JHM.
The only think I would add is that you should only entertain this idea IF PIM is counted in your league. That is one statistical category that Getzlaf has a clear advantage in.
That said, if your league has positional requirements I would forget the trade and keep Hossa regardless.
my league has PIMs giving negative points, and C/RW/LW. I had to trade Getzlaf AND Enstrom to get Hossa, and i\'m quite satisfied with the deal 8 months later.
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
Thanks guys very helpful as always!! I asked the question because Getzlaf is so much higher on Dobbers list then Hossa. Do most of you guys use Dobbers list?
Thanks
15 teams, 1 NHL point=1 point, goalie win=2, shutout=3, PIM=0.2
Must have 10 forwards,4 Defensemen,1 Goalie active in line up from bench of 25. Line up set once a week. 6 keepers
My Team
Forwards: Ovechkin,Kovalchuk,Roy,Hossa,Zherdev,Huselius,Staj an,Upshall,Wheeler, Frolov,Horcoff,Lombardi,Andrei Kostitsyn,MacArthur,Hanzal
Defensemen:Goligoski,Whitney,Martin,McCabe,Robidas
Goalie:Rinne,Leighton
Should I trade Marian Hossa for Ryan Getzlaf?
are you talking about his sleeperpotential or just the stated one?
Posting Permissions