Semin or Satan ?

[kitimat kid]

Alexander Semin or Miroslav Satan ?

[Scribe]

Semin.

Don\'t overrate the Crosby factor. If both play a full season the best Sid can do for Satan is help him equal Semin.

I predict a bust out season for the Russian.

[JHM]

The only potential environment inwhich this can truly be a question is a one year pool. Go ahead, take whichever you\'re more comfortable with. Crosby factor, Semin injury factor, Ovy factor, the Malkin factor, the Backstrom factor...

Every other pool you must take Semin for the AGE FACTOR and the potential associated with that.

It\'s clear that Satan is in the autumn of career. Semin is in the spring. Should Semin play 80 games and find the \'big form\', you can certainly wonder about point-per-game stuff.

[NYR9394]

Semin.

[Pavel Bure]

Semin without question. Doesn\'t matter what type of league.

[natgeo]

I truly believe Semin could hit 90-100 points in his career year. He is THAT good and the team he plays on is stellar. Of course, that won\'t be for a few years IMO.