Pleaese create your TIERS

[DobberManiac]

I need to split these rookies/prospects in to max 3 tiers for a keeper league pts only league.
tier 1 being the best and most safest player to reach 75+ pts in their prime consistently
tier 2 being 60-75 pts prime consistently
tier 3 being 50-60 pts in prime consistently


Svechnikov
tolvenen
zadina
donato
Henrik Borgstrom
necas
gourde
Labanc
Vesalainen
Wahlstrom
Dahlen
debrusk
Val Zykov,
dylan sikura -
Abramov
gaudette
Roslovic
Ondrej Kase
robert thomas
Troy Terry
kyrou
viliardi
kerfoot
milano
josh anderson
Christian Fischer
Hinostroza
Tuch
Lias Andersson
Filip Chytil
Ryan Dzingel
Jordan Greenway
heinen
andeas johnson
sazuki

I know gourde may already be in his prime. what is his floor?

WILL REP

[Eskimo Brother]

The line between their 2 and 3 is going to be so fine here I won't even try.

I will give a little bit of insight into my thinking though.

Tier 1:
Svech
Tolvanen
Zadina
Necas

HM for likely tier 2:
Thomas
Borgstrom
Suzuki
Whalstrom
Debrusk
Vilardi

[DobberManiac]

The line between their 2 and 3 is going to be so fine here I won't even try.

I will give a little bit of insight into my thinking though.

Tier 1:
Svech
Tolvanen
Zadina
Necas

HM for likely tier 2:
Thomas
Borgstrom
Suzuki
Whalstrom
Debrusk
Vilardi

thank you my man, I appreciate this. so i guess you feel the rest of the names on my list are in tier 3?

[Eskimo Brother]

Not necessarily. Probably 50-50 for the rest of them falling into tier 2 or three, but the HM list I had there is the cream of the crop of tier 2.
Or if you want to make it four tiers, you're got my tier 1 and 2 listed above, with the rest being a jumbled mess of personal preference to make tier 3 and 4.

[DobberManiac]

Not necessarily. Probably 50-50 for the rest of them falling into tier 2 or three, but the HM list I had there is the cream of the crop of tier 2.
Or if you want to make it four tiers, you're got my tier 1 and 2 listed above, with the rest being a jumbled mess of personal preference to make tier 3 and 4.

seems I can't provide you with REP as you have too much lol... but I see what you are saying. then about this tierX of 2nd -3rd year fwrds...how do you rank these guys against each other or who do you see as a legit 60pts guy in order of preference...
Ryan Dzingel
Tuch
Lebanc
kase
Kerfoot
debrusk
Heinen
fischer
gourde

I see donato did not really make any of your top tiers?? everyone and their grandma seem so high on this guy...

[Figu]

I'll follow this post as I am in similar situation (see my thread)

Eskimo Brother, useful as always.

[Eskimo Brother]

DeBrusk
Tuch
Gourde
Kase
Labanc

- - - Updated - - -

And yeah, don't know why I'm not as high on Donato. Just hasn't convinced me yet that he's worth the hype.

[chuckcouples]

I am only going to do my Tier 1 for you:

Tier 1 - consistent 75+ point getters





That's it.

Over the past 4 seasons, the NHL has averaged about sixteen 75 point men per season. I don't think any of the guys you listed are going to consistently be in the top 20 in NHL scoring so I can't list any of them as Tier 1 players.

[vandalay]

Tier 1:
Svechnikov

Tier 2 (in no particular order):
Tolvanen
Zadina
Necas
Vesalainen
Wahlstrom

[Dover]

Tier1: Svechnikov

Tier2: Tolvanen
Zadina
Vesalainen
Necas
Kase
Roslovic
Borgstrom
Thomas

[rd69]

I wouldn't tier them quite like you, but I'll treat them as: Tier 1 - 70+ points, Tier 2 - 65+ points, Tier 3 - 55+ points, Tier 4 - 45+ points.

Tier 1:

Svechnikov
Tolvanen
Zadina
Necas

Tier 2:

Borgstrom
Wahlstrom
Vesalainen
Vilardi
Thomas
Suzuki
Kyrou

Tier 3:

DeBrusk
Chytil
Andersson
Sikura
Gourde
Donato
Labanc
Kase
Roslovic
Tuch

Tier 4:

Heinen
Johnsson
Abramov
Zykov
Milano
Dahlen
Gaudette
Terry
Kerfoot
Anderson
Greenway
Fischer
Hinostroza
Dzingel

[DobberManiac]

So no one sees Zykov or terry as 30-30 players?
also I see Abramov not getting any love...apparently he is the next debrincat/gaudreau as the game is letting these little shifty guys flourish?

[Figu]

I like rd69's way of grouping them. Some of the TIER3-4 could florish and get 60ish but other than that it looks solid starting ground.