Arvidsson vs keller vs guentzel

[z420-81]

Have our draft coming real soon and I think by the time I get to pick in the 1st round, one of the 3 will be still available. There is a chance all 3 are still available and if that is the case, who would be the best option. Being a salary cap keeper league (money is not an issue for me and all teams are always contenders), Guentzel is the best bang for the buck but only for one more year after this year and then who knows how much he signs for. Now of course Keller is at a low salary for the next 3 years but if he turns out to be who everyone thinks he will be, his next contract will be big. Arvidsson is locked in for the next 5 years at a really good contract but is he going to put up the same numbers as the other 2 in 3 years time? When it gets to my pick and all 3 are available, who should I take?

[RizzeeDizzee]

In a 7 team league you need home runs, which, along with it being straight points, removes Arvy from the equation IMO. I'm down on Guentzel, so if it was me I'd opt for Keller. But that's just me.

[Nehithaw]

Another Keller vote from me - He's gonna be a beauty. He will earn his money for you now, worry about his salary later.

[STONE.]

I'd be gambling on Keller too, and I actually like the other two guys just fine.
I think Rizzee's thoughts on the home run are generally the way to go. And I think Keller puts up enough points this year to not be a total black hole for you -- could compete for your 12th F spot.
Guentzel would be next for me -- also has home run potential alongside Sid.
Arvidsson I own, and like, but put him third here. I don't see you keeping him, and in a league this small (seven teams), he's not super special.

At a glance, I have a tough time thinking your team is among the top ones in a league this size, so go for upside.