I'm Overthinking Value for Keepers..

[Bobz]

Edit:
Thxs all for confirming my selections, +Rep'ed all

[hockeymanG23]

You have it figured out. Burns, Kucherov, Panarin, Gibson, and Marner are by far the best options you have here.

[The Bottlenecker]

I like how you thought things through, but I'd stick with your gut instinct and keep the five HockeymanG23 listed.

[jdreed3184]

Yeah, I can understand the attraction to the other options but your original keepers are the ones I'd choose.

[DAAKS]

If I'm in your shoes I keep Marner and I'm really happy with that value. My last keeper would be a goalie. If you think the goalie market will be tight I may lean towards keeping Rask over Gibson but if you think a top flight goalie will be there for the taking with the 57th pick maybe you keep Gibson and roll the dice.

[Magicstew]

You have it figured out. Burns, Kucherov, Panarin, Gibson, and Marner are by far the best options you have here.

This is the way I would go too, you have to look at where they would go if they weren't keep, also what are your odds of drafting this type of player again at this position. Most of the other guys you can get a comparable player at the same position. Only other guy may look at is Foligno, not sure how much higher he would go. The other option is can you do any trades on someone like Foligno for a draft pick, to even move up a round or two somewhere. The guys that win you these type of drafts is the late rounders who perform above expectations.