theodore for cammalleri, ryder, liles, S.Kostitsyn

[notoriousjim]

10 teams, 25 man rosters, g,a,gwg, +/-, pim, ppp, sog for skaters, gaa, so, saves, wins, sv% for goalies. We start 2c, 2lw, 2rw, 4d, 2 goalies. We keep our full rosters from year to year.

A point of reference is jordan staal and brad richards were traded for vokoun. A variation of this trade was vetoed (it was reworked to appease the other managers.) so guess what side was getting ripped.

WHat does everyone think of this trade. What side is getting the better end?

[notoriousjim]

i thought this would get more attention. It is a deal that originally had Malone on the theodore side, and not kosteitsyn. THat got vetoed. THis was what was worked out the 2nd time.

I was getting theodore, and the sentiment was i was getting too good of a deal. The manager on the other side got really defensive, and offered every team that voted agianst it a trade that had their younger 80 point forward and younger D for theodore, was was shot down by every one.

In the end, he has re offered the trade for a third time, this time re dropping kostitsyn. I want to do it, but when a trade is vetoed twice, there has to be a reason that i am not seeing.