Marner or Tatar?

[tweetdrivr]

G, A, +/-, PP, SH, Hits

Marner or Tatar for this season?
Thanks

[lucafen4]

Go for the homerun. I like Marner. but it's going to be close. Should give more points, but Tatar should outshoot him. I wouldn't count on +/- from either.

[Cake Eater]

I think out of the young kids in Toronto Marner will have the best season. That is even over Matthews.

[PatyOFurniture]

Tatar for me.. i'll take the proven guy
but if you want to gamble...

[havanablast21]

Marner for me. +\- will eventually fall in line.

But this kid is one of the most exciting players, let alone prospects in the league at the moment.

[The Iron Sheik]

Tatar for sure. I wouldn't want marner in a one year as I think he'll slow down like most non superstar rookies do.

[Eskimo Brother]

Marner for me as well. He's one of the top of the league in 5on5 points per 60 minutes for a reason. Add a few more minutes to his game and he is going to take off.

[The Iron Sheik]

Marner for me as well. He's one of the top of the league in 5on5 points per 60 minutes for a reason. Add a few more minutes to his game and he is going to take off.

That stat is often flawed. Points don't increase on a consistent slope with more time on ice.

[havanablast21]

He's the better player in my mind and especially in this set up. Could he cool? Perhaps. Could he win the Calder? I see no reason why he can't. Someone forgot to tell the Breadman to slow down last year.

EV doesn't consider Marner a superstar rookie. Doesn't surprise me. I consider him a bonafide Star prospect. Panarin was also never Considered a "Superstar" and who Wouldn't have wanted him last year?

Tatar is very good. Marner could be even better! And yes... I feelIt could happen this year. If I want to play big, play BOLD and play To Win... I'm taking Marner.

Good luck.

[The Iron Sheik]

He's the better player in my mind and especially in this set up. Could he cool? Perhaps. Could he win the Calder? I see no reason why he can't. Someone forgot to tell the Breadman to slow down last year.

EV doesn't consider Marner a superstar rookie. Doesn't surprise me. I consider him a bonafide Star prospect. Panarin was also never Considered a "Superstar" and who Wouldn't have wanted him last year?

Tatar is very good. Marner could be even better! And yes... I feelIt could happen this year. If I want to play big, play BOLD and play To Win... I'm taking Marner.

Good luck.

No I don't consider him a superstar rookie. I consider Matthews and laine that. And nylander is better even.

[havanablast21]

No I don't consider him a superstar rookie. I consider Matthews and laine that. And nylander is better even.

Yes. You already said that. And I sighted the fact that you said that very thing and I also said that it didn't surprise me that you said that. That's your perogative.

I simply stated where you and I are different which could help the OP make up his own mind.

I feel you are underrating Marner and furthermore I believe him to be a star prospect in the making.

Up to the OP to decide what he thinks.

[tweetdrivr]

Thanks guys. I took a close look and dropped Kadri for Marner instead. So I'm rolling with both right now.

[havanablast21]

Good choice!

[The Iron Sheik]

Not a move I would have made. Kadri will otuproduce marner no question.

[Leafs2010]

Marner AINEC