Which 6 should I keep for next season?

[pmkidd]

So it comes down to final 2 spots. League in Sig. Malkin can't be keeper. Only players not drafted rds 1-8 can be keepers. Would like to keep 1 goalie. D gets bonus pts

Hall (lock)
Giroux (lock)
Buff (lock)
OEL (lock)

From this list which 2
Ghost
SCHEIFELE
Ehlers
Mason
Hellebuyck

[Axeman33]

Considering you already have two D as keepers, it makes it damn tough to keep Gostisbehere but also damn tough to let him go too.

I also am not sold on keeping either of your current goalies but it's hard to give goalie advice without knowing what may or may not be available for redrafting. In a 14 team league, your goalies are not very good if Mason is your key starter. Is there any way you can deal away someone like Gostisbehere and/or Hellebuyck for a better, high end goalie?? Just spitballin on that one.

I have no issues letting Scheifele go in this format but I would want to find a way to retain Ehlers. I do agree with your locks though.

If it's me, I am trying to move some sort of combination of Gostisbehere, Hellebuyck or Mason for a goalie upgrade to become one of your keepers.

[lucafen4]

for me it would be Ghost & Ehlers, highest ceiling players Ehlers less effected by another bad Jets season next year than Helle & Ehlers over Scheifele due to ceiling/expectations. Scheifele is a close 3rd to Ehlers for me

[StuntMan12]

The GHOST and Ehlers for me.

[bondon]

I'd take Gostisbehere and Scheifele. Toss up between Scheifele and Mason for the last spot if you really need a goalie.

With D-points being the butter on top I'm ok with keeping 3 (expected) high producing d.

[martinc84]

Ghost and Ehlers! Definitively!

[Oakville Squires]

I would go Ghost and Hellebuyck (it would be close between Hellebuyck and Ehlers for me).

[Wonko]

Gostisbehere and Ehlers.

[Instant Karma]

I would go Ghost and Hellebuyck (it would be close between Hellebuyck and Ehlers for me).

+1. In your position I'd be willing to roll the dice that Hellebuyck ends up as the starter there. That's assuming you can't improve your goalie situation otherwise.

[The Guvnah]

You have to keep Ghost here. If you must keep a G, I'd go with Hellebuyck, but as Axeman suggested, I'd try to engineer a trade to upgrade that position because I think either Ehlers or Scheifele would be good keepers as well. I guess, with the goalie situation if you can't make a trade, I'd be asking myself what will be available at the draft and is Hellebuyck a true upgrade over that?

[Referee3083]

Is there any way you can deal away someone like Gostisbehere and/or Hellebuyck for a better, high end goalie?

This is exactly what I was thinking. Hellebuyck might not even get regular starting time next year (if the Jets were smart, he would, but they've shown quite the ability to not make smart goaltending choices). I'd be looking to get a solid #1 goalie and use whatever non / fringe keeper players you have to get one.

[finnys_fanatsy]

agreed with some that Ghost is a hard choice to let go..but until he repeats his success i'd be hesitant to bank on it again so bundling him and Helly into a package for a goalie upgrade is key here. Find the guy that has the weakest d corps

Tap into Ghosts hype and upgrade the G-spot.

Ehlers is my second keeper.

[Wonko]

agreed with some that Ghost is a hard choice to let go..but until he repeats his success i'd be hesitant to bank on it again so bundling him and Helly into a package for a goalie upgrade is key here. Find the guy that has the weakest d corps

Tap into Ghosts hype and upgrade the G-spot.

Ehlers is my second keeper.

Agreed. If you can cash in on the Ghost train for a number 1 tier tender I would make the move.

[LuigiC173]

Schiefele/Ghost

[pmkidd]

Might put Ghost on the block and see if can trade for goalie upgrade. Then down to Ehlers or SCHEIFELE.