Stamkos/gagne/sedin 3rd 4 Biron/chara/Brichards 1s

[Citadel32]

the team that traded stamkos is challenging for the title this year with

Lecav
spezz
Parise
M.Green
D.roy
B.Boyes

Vokoun
Turco

(note this deal will occur after the draft, as this owner has to old a max of 8 in order to pick stamkos as 1st overall)

now add
Chara, Biron, Richards.

the team that recieved Stamkos is in a rebuilding stage that looks like this

St. louis.
Whitney

Osgood
Giguere

And the traded players.

Format, g,a,+/-,pims,ppp,gwg,shots, GAA, SV%, So\'s, wins.

Just trying to get a feel of what everyone thinks in order to debate whether or not I can still beat this guy (amongst others) even after this trade.

[JHM]

Stamkos - 1st (very possibly Tavares?) (I\'d take the risk for top 3 pick)
Gagne - B. Richards (I\'ll take Richards)
Sedin - Biron (different strokes for different folks) (If D. Sedin then I\'ll take the winger)
3rd - Chara (I\'ll take Chara)

Hmmm. I\'m not feeling very decisive on one side or the other. Fair trade that should only go through if it addresses the needs of both teams.

[reeveta]

I had a bit of a hard time following all the details of the situation but the short of my opinion is that in a multi-category league, that required defenceman, Chara is gold. He is by far the best player in the deal and the rest of the players are not enough to sway me from that side.