Another Mcdavid thread : help!

[Overated Veteran]

So there's a guy offering me Eichel + Mackinnon for Mcdavid straight up. I know I could even ask for more (like pick n.15) and he would probably accept it

Is it a no brainer? I feel like it would be a Malkin + Getlzaf for Crosby back when they were young. No need to say I'd rather have 71 & 15 over Sidney

[Dobber]

I think your comparison MacKinnon=Getzlaf is aggressive and Eichel=Malkin too. But even dialing back the comparables a little, like maybe Tavares + Kopitar for Crosby, it's close, especially if you get the pick too. However, in limited keeper leagues, each keeper spot is worth so much more than if it were an unlimited keeper. So you want maximized value for each roster spot. I'm leaning towards no here.

[fungchen3]

Dobber makes a rock solid point - all depends on your keepers. The "value" is there but if you need to drop someone like Domi, Barkov or Bennett to fit both Eichel and MacK, it's not as a sweetheart deal at all. I don't think I would trade McDavid and S.Bennett for Eichel and MacKinnon, but that's me.