Guy wants my Stanton

[2014olympicgold]

Someone all yr has wanted Stanton from me. It’s his favourite player and I was naïve enough to decline a solid offer for him earlier in the yr. Now I’ve come into the talks level headed. My team is:
Batters:
C: McCann (C, 1B), 1B: Trumbo (1B,OF), 2B: Altuve (2B), 3B: Donaldson (3B), SS: Brandon Crawford (SS), IF: Gordon (2B), OF (5): Stanton (OF), Brantley (OF), Braun (OF), Pederson (OF), Polanco (OF), UTIL: Gallo (3B).
Pitchers:
SP(3): Hamels, Gray, Arrieta
RP(2) Rondon, K-Rod
P(4): Papelbon (RP), Tolleson (RP), Allen (RP), Salazar (SP)
BN: Wood (SP,RP), C.Martinez (SP,RP)
DL: Moore (SP), Cain (SP)

Just through some quick texts he asked what I wanted and I said a 3for2 or 2for1 with 1B, and SP. He said he “Rizzo, Harvey but that’s a lot don’t you think?” then came back and offered “ Rizzo, Hamilton, and a pitcher for Stanton”. I was really hoping for a 2 leaving, 1 coming back thing so I can get Moore in the lineup later on.

[2014olympicgold]

Stats are:
10 team Roto (Keep 7 Bolded)
Batters: Runs, HR, RBI, SB, Avg, OPS
Pitchers: W, ERA, WHIP, K/9, QS, Sv+H

Rizzo, Goldschmidt, Harper, Adam Jones, Billy Hamilton, Matt Harvey, Wacha, and Jose Fernandez are the guys I like on his team.

[StressQ]

Goldy and JoFer is who I would target off that list.

If you want two out and one in... I'd through in one of your RP and see if that gets it done for Goldy.

[TheNugeCooge]

Rizzo and Goldschmidt are almost equal for me in a keeper so if he wants to sweeten the deal with Rizzo ++ I'd let him.

Aim for Rizzo and Jose Fernandez and you'll be laughing

[MacLiii]

Truthfully, The Rizzo Harvey offer is a very solid offer for Stanton, but you already have two of the top SP in Gray and Hamels; although, in a Keeper league at the end of this year, with only 7 keepers, I'd be keeping the two 25 year old SP in Harvey and Gray vs Hamels especially if Hamels gets traded to the AL when Philly finally pulls the trigger.

[2014olympicgold]

ok don't quite know how i got this

My Stanton, Polanco, Salazar, Wood

For

Rizzo, Billy Hamilton, Wacha, Harvey.

UMMMM, win much?

[GinFizz]

Ill take the Stanton side..

[djkiang]

Yes, the 2-1 turned out to be a more even deal for the Stanton owner. Good trade for you if you're in contention as you get the more stable pitching

[StressQ]

Basically Stanton for Rizzo and Harvey - I like it.

[2014olympicgold]

Well obviously Stanton heard the news and went on a tear since the trade. But I bolstered my 1B position, and added a fair bit of arms. While I saw my HR lead shrink, my ERA, QS, and W have increased. Would I do it again? Maybe get someone else instead of Hamilton but no issue with this trade for me.

Thanks for the input