Duchene/OEL/Bernier for Bishop/Wheeler

[Front89]

Need some help on evaluating a trade offer...

Bishop(11) + Wheeler(11) for Duchene(22) + OEL(14) + Bernier(10) - the numbers in () are those player's cap units next year if I kept them.

My roster, cats and cap number details are in my signature below

I'm currently in 3rd place and within hailing distance of the lead, but am also aware I can only keep 9 and thus need to make a compression trade (2 for 1 or 3 for 2) to try and get some
better keeper options.

The keepers I am planning on keeping are in bold below (Benn, Pavelski, Pacioretty, Oshie, Palat, Shatts, Burns, Holtby and Bernier).

However, I'd like to upgrade Bernier if possible and want to see if I can get a better F than Oshie or Palat. The main reason I'm keeping Oshie & Palat are because they are very good players and have very low cap unit numbers for next year.

Bishop is an upgrade on Bernier IMO, but I need to know the consensus if Wheeler is a better keeper than Oshie or Palat and need to know overall how people view this trade for me this year and next year.

Thanks for the help

[Riverboat Danglers]

Bishop would be a huge upgrade over your current goaltenders. He is by far the best player in this deal. As for Oshie or Wheeler, I feel that they are pretty much a wash for me at this stage in their careers. Wheeler was a bit better last year but Oshie is starting to develop into a decent player that could rank near the top 50. Personally I would take the Bishop side on this one.