Josi or Spurgeon over Ehrhoff?

[Carlito99]

Spurgeon and Josi are both sitting on the FA list in my league right now, and Ehrhoff really hasn't done much of anything. Should I replace him with either Spurgeon or Josi?

One thing to note is that, using the same night tool and setting 3 rostered players (TB - Hedman, TB - Gudas, SJ - Burns) with 2 starting positions, I get the following results (as of Nov 17 - yes I know Hedman isn't back, but he should be within the next couple of weeks so that's why I'm including him)

Pittsburgh - Ehrhoff: 34 starts
Minnesota - Spurgeon: 27 Starts
Josi - Nashville: 23 starts

Thanks as always

[zeptowl]

I would take Josi. Josi gets a ton of blocks and he's playing EV and on PP1 with Weber. Ehrhoff is good but currently buried under other offensive D men so his value is limited.

[Mr. Guru]

Spurgeon.

Played about 29min per game since returning from his injury (3 games) and isn't afraid to block shots either.

[Doug Glatt]

Spurgeon. He's breaking out in a big way this year. Lots of SOG and blocks.