Pierre McGuire is wrong thread

[mister_mcgoo]

post here every time he is \'sure\' of a pick and is flat out wrong...it will likely happen a LOT.

I just started watching so I mighta missed a few already (probably not, the first handful are almost set in stone) but post them if i missed any. Just heard this one:

-round 7: he called a goalie for some reason (didn\'t catch the name)...I might be missing something but I don\'t recall a goaltender that I had anywhere in my top 30, nevermind 9th overall

[lanky522]

mister_mcgoo wrote:

post here every time he is \'sure\' of a pick and is flat out wrong...it will likely happen a LOT.

I just started watching so I mighta missed a few already (probably not, the first handful are almost set in stone) but post them if i missed any. Just heard this one:

-round 9: he called a goalie for some reason (didn\'t catch the name)...I might be missing something but I don\'t recall a goaltender that I had anywhere in my top 30, nevermind 9th overall

especially since NYI is picking 9th

[mister_mcgoo]

oops that was a typo, shoulda been a \'7\', I fixed it

[mister_mcgoo]

Mcguire clearly has a woody for all goaltenders, he called for Chet Pickard at 15...hard to beat him up over this one though, it would have made sense

[mister_mcgoo]

yayyyyy Pierre, if you call it every pick eventually you\'re gonna be right...lol. Not a bad pick for the Preds though, I personally didn\'t have him going till the early 2nd round but that was prior to the Mason trade

[mister_mcgoo]

on Lucas Sbisa *sigh* this is a direct quote:

\"you know who he\'s just like? He\'s just like a guy that plays for the Montreal Canadiens, or did...a Swiss guy. He\'s exactly like Mark Streit...Yes, Lucas Sbisa is just like Mark Streit, very versatile, good puck mover, good decisions, run the PP, and he can play forward... \"

wtf??? I watched this guy play in international play and was impressed by his composure and poise both defensively and on the PP so in that I\'m in agreement, but how is he exactly like Streit and a candidate to play forward? Because he\'s Swiss??? I\'m sorry I hate to rant but this is why I cant stand PM, I think he\'s got McKenzies cheat sheet in front of him so he stays more or less on track but when he starts rambling on his own he says some of the stupidest shit.

[sabe]

mister_mcgoo wrote:

I think he\'s got McKenzies cheat sheet in front of him so he stays more or less on track but when he starts rambling on his own he says some of the stupidest shit.

Can\'t agree more. +1 Karma for you.

[lockedge]

Pierre made some good analysis all night, but there were a few times I was shaking my head. Some minor ones (Jason McBain instead of Jamie McBain), and some major ones, like dissing nashville\'s goaltending pipeline. And saying Florida made a great trade with phoenix. A few times he made mistakes about some prospects(at least, in my mind), though I\'ll let it slide because he always says these kids are monsters, or whatnot.