H.Sedin/Stastny/Carter/M.Staal/Latendresse for

[InForAPenny]

Horton/Zherdev/St.Louis/Bieksa/Olesz/Voracek

Who wins this. As you can see from my signature I own the Stastny component. It really depends on how good Stastny and Carter can be as I have considered moving the other three before.

If Columbus ever managed to get and offence I would have Nash/Zherdev/Brule/Voracek.

I really dislike the idea of parting with Stastny. I\'m a couple of years out from winning so will St.Louis still be there? How good can Horton and Olesz be?

Maybe if I took out Bieksa and Olesz and asked for Timonen instead.

I really am not sure as I have somewhat fallen into the trap of liking the guys on my team too much. (Even if I am not yet cometitive. Damnit!

[smack]

I think you\'d be losing this trade. Sedin, Stastny and Carter are very good and I don\'t see you getting fair value in return.

I also think you have enough BJ\'s and say away from the rest (even though I really like Voracek). If PIM\'s counted, I\'d say to consider this more but points only I wouldnt\'.

[Zorro]

I would rather have:

H.Sedin/Stastny/Carter over Horton/St.Louis/Zherdev

and would rather have:

Voracek and Bieska over Latendresse and M.Staal

This would be a hard deal for me to accept if I was on the Sedin/Stastny/Carter side. I would love to get my hands on Bieska and Voracek but wouldn\'t want to give up on Stastny and Carter. I am not a fan of Zherdev but love Horton. I just don\'t think St.Louis will put up the 90-100 point seasons for much longer..

If you can take Stastny and Zherdev out of the deal I would do the deal..

H.Sedin/Carter/M.Staal/Latendresse
for
Horton/St.Louis/Bieska/Voracek

[Zorro]

That was another point I wanted to point out, if PIM\'s are not counted I wouldn\'t even think of accepting the deal especially the other deal I said at the end of my last message..
Z..

I just wouldn\'t want to have Horton and Bieska in this deal as bad if PIM\'s aren\'t counted. But I think you should try and get your hands on Voracek.

[canada]

smack1919 wrote:

I also think you have enough BJ\'s

that\'s what she said


...


sorry I had to

given you said you\'re a little way from competing i\'d stick with the carter side.

[InForAPenny]

About time someone came up with that\'s what she said...I get the strangest looks when I say it!

Thank you all for the advice...Voracek is one I have wanted to get my hands on for a while, I usually try to add him into deals so its not like he\'s a target, more a throw in. Is there anyone on my roster that might land him...fellow prospect B.Ryan perhaps...maybe worth moving Brule, not that I want to give up on him just yet.

Thanks again guys...sometimes I get stuck on my guys and other times I almost want to make trades just to shake it up...I like the balanced opinios on the forums.

[ultrawhiteness]

i would definitely consider moving ryan or brule for voracek. hell, i\'d move both of them for him.