Chris Johnson for McFadden and Powell

[Brosive]

This offer was proposed to me

HIS McFadden and Powell for MY Chris Johnson

we start 3 RBs

Currently i have Spiller, Johnson, Matthews, Fred Jackson, and Bell

Johnson gets absolutely no goal line carries.. McFadden is hot and cold a lot, plus injury prone.. Powell is a short term option for now until Ivory is back, but he could work his way into a bigger role

Its a keep 8 league so only Johnson or McFadden would carry over to next year most likely..

which of the 2 would you rather roll with?

Thanks

[CronoX]

I'd roll w CJ, no doubt. People still have faith in him. McFadden is too inconsistent to ever start & Powell is just a "sell high" player. When CJ pulls a monster game this year (its guaranteed he will), you can trade him for a lot more to another GM who thinks he's back to his old form.

[Mattp913]

McFadden is better than CJ straight up IMO so I would definitely take McFadden+Powell for CJ.