Giguere for (Gomez + Nylander) + Liles

[kytmagic]

H2H Keeper League with standard categories

C: Cammalleri, Stastny
LW: Kovalchuk, Vanek
RW: Jagr, Iginla
D: Lidstrom, Gonchar, Visnovsky
G: Turco, Emery, Giguere

Is he giving enough or not enough?

[BrianSTC]

Need more info....like how many players are you allowed on your team, etc.

Keep in mind:
Gomez should play with Jagr.
Nylander should play with Ovechkin.

But your team looks fairly good as it is...

[QStar]

BrianSTC wrote:

Need more info....like how many players are you allowed on your team, etc.

Keep in mind:
Gomez should play with Jagr.
Nylander should play with Ovechkin.

But your team looks fairly good as it is...

Yes definitely need more info as to roster size and # of starters and positional requirements. How many teams are in the league?

I think adding Nylander and Gomez would be an upgrade from Cam + Stastny, but it looks like he\'s trying to pull the old quantity for quality and inducing you into dropping either Cam/Stastny for him to pick up.

I agree with the statement that your team looks fairly solid already. Your goalie group is strong enough to put you in a situation to where it\'s very easy to win every week using standard yahoo H2H cats.

[kytmagic]

Sorry guys. 12 team league.

We play 4 Cs, 4 LWs, 4 RWs, 6 Ds and 2 Gs.

This trade is to be done prior to the draft we are about to have.

[Loki]

As much as I\'d hate to drop Giguere, I think it\'s a fair deal. It rounds out your 4 C\'s nicely and Liles is a nice touch.

[Egon]

I think it depends on what goalies are available in your draft. If the best you can get is a backup then this isnt worth it since goaltenting wins fantasy championships.

[smoothfun]

good statement,goalies are the hardest to replace once they\'re gone.more than once i\'ve traded a good goalie for excellent players ,only to have it bite me in the ass later, yet here again i like what you\'re being offered , but remember giguire has proven that he is among the best.