Vanek Vs Sharp

[Rocky71]

Points only(G=1, A=1) limited keeper, no positional requirements. Who would you rather own in this format?

[Mattp913]

I'd go with Vanek

[yougo]

I own Vanek and Sharp in one of my leagues, and this is a tough one. I feel like Sharp is more consistent while Vanek has streaks where he plays like a top10 player in the league then he disappears for a month....

Because of that, I much prefer Sharp. No headaches, I know what I'm getting out of him.

[Bristol]

Both are a bit injury prone to a degree, but I think I would give a slight edge to sharp.

[kevinsrangers]

id prefer sharp.

[mr_long1990]

If this is a H2H league, I'd go with Vanek simply because his streaks can sometimes win matchups.

[als_revenge]

Arguments can be made either way, and there is no right or wrong answer. For me, in a keeper pool, I'd go Vanek. I think he can put up numbers close to Sharp this year. And I think he'll be out of Buffalo, and in a much better position, next year.

[Mattp913]

Riduclously tough to compare but Ill gove it a shot

Crosby
McDavid
Tavares
Stamkos
Hall

[als_revenge]

Riduclously tough to compare but Ill gove it a shot

Crosby
McDavid
Tavares
Stamkos
Hall

LOL. I think this is for another thread. You must be as tired as I am today