Rank these Keepers...

[DareDevil]

Morrow, Parise, Toews, Backstrom, M.Richards, Perry, D.Sedin, H.Sedin

Take into acct the position the players play...

[Crazynuck]

What are the scoring categories of your league???

[tybiggs]

Hello and welcome! It would be easier if you added league categories.

hahah doh!

[smack]

Without knowing the scoring and the positional requirements I\'d rank them as:

Backstrom, Parise, Toews, D. Sedin, Perry, H. Sedin, Morrow, M. Richards.

[jman]

w/o categories given:

backstrom, toews, richards, dsedin, hsedin, parise, perry morrow

[ultrawhiteness]

assuming standard h2h/roto cats...

backstrom, richards, toews, perry, morrow, d sedin, parise, h sedin

but, positional requirements could totally change everything

[mapletreemarty]

Well he said to take into account the positions they play so I would have to say:

Backstrom
Perry
Parise
M. Richards
D. Sedin
Toews
Morrow
H.Sedin

[DareDevil]

WOW, so many different opinions!

Here are the categories...G-A-PPP-PIM-SHP-SOG-SH%

3LW/3C/3RW no UTIL and 5 BENCH

I was thinking Parise and Morrow would be higher because of the LW status.

[ultrawhiteness]

mapletreemarty wrote:

Well he said to take into account the positions they play so I would have to say:

Backstrom
Perry
Parise
M. Richards
D. Sedin
Toews
Morrow
H.Sedin

yeah, i say that, i meant that if he needed a particular position then the list would change... i would like to have a lot of those guys on my team and don\'t think i could give an absolute rank for some of those young centers and wingers.

backstrom, to me, is the only must-have guy on that list, and i might be tempted to pick him even if i needed wingers badly.

after that, if you need a LW, go parise and then morrow (although, if your team is light on PIMs or if you think you can dominate that category, then Morrow might be first).

if you need RW, then perry is the guy to get.

[DareDevil]

ultrawhiteness wrote:

mapletreemarty wrote:

Well he said to take into account the positions they play so I would have to say:

Backstrom
Perry
Parise
M. Richards
D. Sedin
Toews
Morrow
H.Sedin

yeah, i say that, i meant that if he needed a particular position then the list would change... i would like to have a lot of those guys on my team and don\'t think i could give an absolute rank for some of those young centers and wingers.

backstrom, to me, is the only must-have guy on that list, and i might be tempted to pick him even if i needed wingers badly.

after that, if you need a LW, go parise and then morrow (although, if your team is light on PIMs or if you think you can dominate that category, then Morrow might be first).

if you need RW, then perry is the guy to get.

Backstrom seems like a one-category guy...Assists only...am I missing something?

[Crazynuck]

Welcome DareDevil,

with those catgories:

Backstrom
Toews
D.Sedin
Perry
Parise
M.Richards
Morrow
H.Sedin

[Buck Fush]

ultrawhiteness wrote:

assuming standard h2h/roto cats...

backstrom, richards, toews, perry, morrow, d sedin, parise, h sedin

but, positional requirements could totally change everything

I really like this list, since SHP are involved Richards has to be high as he will be an elite pk producer and all around stat stuffer. I would also take perry morrow dsedin over parise and henrik, and maybe (just maybe) over toews as well because of positional requirements.

[Buck Fush]

DareDevil wrote:

ultrawhiteness wrote:

mapletreemarty wrote:

Well he said to take into account the positions they play so I would have to say:

Backstrom
Perry
Parise
M. Richards
D. Sedin
Toews
Morrow
H.Sedin

yeah, i say that, i meant that if he needed a particular position then the list would change... i would like to have a lot of those guys on my team and don\'t think i could give an absolute rank for some of those young centers and wingers.

backstrom, to me, is the only must-have guy on that list, and i might be tempted to pick him even if i needed wingers badly.

after that, if you need a LW, go parise and then morrow (although, if your team is light on PIMs or if you think you can dominate that category, then Morrow might be first).

if you need RW, then perry is the guy to get.

Backstrom seems like a one-category guy...Assists only...am I missing something?

I haven\'t bought into the hype... he is obviously going to be a big time scorer and he has loads of talent but I dont think his game translates to fantasy all that well (he wont put up big goals, pims, shp, or shots). I\'m thinking a new and improved Henrik Sedin is what he\'ll end up being.

[VintageVibe]

mapletreemarty has the best rankings considering the categories...maybe switch richards with d sedin.


EDIT: Backstrom WILL be like H Sedin...just a lot better...25 points better on avg for the next 15 years (when comparing to H Sedins best season to date)

[Qetuoadg]

Toews
Parise
Backstrom
Perry
Morrow
D. Sedin
M. Richards
H.Sedin