Kemp/A.Ramirez/Uggla for Kinsler/P.Alvarez/Melky

[swampmule]

Hiya

Who wins:

Kemp, Aramis Ramirez, Uggla

for

Kinsler, Pedro Alvarez, Melky Cabrera
?

Thanks!

Yahoo H2H 10 team keeper:
C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, CI, MI, OF, OF, OF, OF, Util, Util

[ruckus1717]

Baring no suspensions for juicing I'd say the kinsler side personally. Kemp can be amazing but is hurt a lot, diddo for aramis but he's getting up in age so probably will see a big decline, uggla stinks... Plus he's old... Kinsler is still a great option at 2nd, Alvarez won't hit high avg but will hit lots of dingers and if melkey is healthy and not suspended he's playing for a potentially great offensive team and should produce!

[dmvincent]

I like the Kinsler side as well.

[dongjohnson]

I disagree. Kinsler strikes out too much, Melky's never going to be the same post suspension and Alvarez is very hot and cold. A fully healthy Kemp blows this out of the water.

[ruckus1717]

Kemp is by far the best player but uggla is absolutely terrible and aramis has also been bad this year paired with his usual injuries he's almost worthless. Kinsler>>>uggla, Alvarez>>aramis, kemp>>>melkey... A younger healthier aramis and its not even close but he and Dan are into their 30s and not getting any better.

[dongjohnson]

I see Melky as worth about a bag of scuffed baseballs, while Ramirez, if healthy, still has pop in his bat. Uggla's not great but he can bonk some bombs even still.