Who would you pick first? HELP!!

[razorbladed]

I have the 5th overall pick in my draft tomorrow (March 27/10) and assuming one of these players will fall to me, who would be the best pick?

Kurt Suzuki - C OAK $15
Elvis Andrus - SS TEX $17
Asdrubal Cabrera - 2B/SS CLE $13
Denard Span - OF MIN $23
Julio Borbon - OF TEX $21
Shin-Soo Choo - OF CLE $27
Brian Roberts - 2B BAL $29
Jason Kubel - OF MIN $16
Brett Anderson - SP OAK $15

My League is $260 Salary Cap/12 Team/AL Only/Keeper/5X5/Snake Draft

I already have the following as my protectables:

Miguel Cabrera - $43
Ian Kinsler - $39
B.J. Upton - 32
Nick Markakis - $29
Carlos Santana - $5

I only have $112 left to spend. Yikes!

[GoldenSeals]

I'd probably go Kubel, Suzuki, or Andrus. Those seem like the best value.