This happens with the quick reply...it was a timely and somewhat costly fix over at DobberHockey. I will definitely take care of this for DobberBaseball, just give me a couple of weeks...
In the meantime, accessing it through this link will solve all your problems (for now it would mean an extra bookmark, sorry)
It's also from accessing threads directly via "last post". If you click the first post and read from there, there shouldn't be a problem. Again - I will have this fixed though.