Vanek, Salo, Comrie for Briere, Stillman, Umberger

[Dobber]

Points only pool. Which side of this deal would you rather be on in a keeper league. No limits on roster spots.

[Jason_Banks]

Vanek, Salo and Comrie...

Umberger seems to offset Salo... and Stillman only has a little while longer...

[gutsandglory]

Briere, Stillman, Umberger

[veronesepk]

Vanek/Salo/Comrie.

[angus]

Vanek, Salo, Comrie.

[CrazyCanuck4]

Vanek, Salo, Comrie

[birddog]

Vanek is the best keeper. Briere had a monster year but is older and more injury prone. Briere and Stillman are also centers a more saturated position.

[GoldenSeals]

If you can win, I like Briere, Stillman, Umberger

[dynamo45]

Vanek, Salo, Comrie... I can see Comrie going to the Caps or Atl

[doulos]

If you\'re going for a win this year then I say Stillman, Briere and Umberger. They should have more points this year combined.

If it\'s long term it\'s a lot closer, but probably the Vanek side by a hair.

[hockeylifer]

You own Vanek. Why would you give up the best player of the bunch? I just don\'t like Comrie. Salo, he is ok.

Briere: He is no comparison to Vanek, in the long term. Stillman... see Comrie comments. Umberger.. I think is overated.

Bottomline, in my world, you have the best player of the bunch. Don\'t trade Vanek.

[smoothfun]

vanek,salo,comrie.

[Dobber]

I own Briere, Umberger and Stillman. If I acquire Salo, I would be dropping him, but putting him in the offer would give the other GM the impression that he\'s getting value for a crappy keeper player. Sometimes that helps to make the offer look better than it is...
Umberger is not a part of my plans, but he is too good to drop.

He turned down the offer, FYI. He has a real hard-on for Vanek.