Reply With QuoteI have 3 of them (Staal, Edler, Benn) on my team.
For this season think its equivalent. Benn>Staal and Edler > Green.
Think Benn and Staal are similar for future, while Edler is safer keeper but Green higher upside/risk
E.Staal and Edler for Benn and Green
Worth it, or just a lateral move? (I would be getting the Benn side)
team/league in sig.
Thanks.
14 Team Dynasty League - 23 man roster, 25 man minors w/ custom cap, salaries & contracts
Skaters: (Start: 4C, 4LW, 4RW, 6D) - G/A/Pt/(+/-)/PIM/SOG/STP/TOI
Goalies: (Start 2) - W/GAA/SV/SV%
C: Schiefele, Zacha, RyJo, Patrick
LW: Guentzel, J.Robertson, Domi, Kempe
RW: Puljujarvi, Gurianov, D.Strome, Duchene
D: Ekblad, E.Karlsson, OEL, Morrissey, Jokiharju, Bear, Weber (LTIR)
G: MAF, Price, Driedger, Bishop (LTIR)
Minors: (25 max)
Skaters: Hayton, JAD, J.Boqvist, Dahlen, Bunting, Gusev, Damiani, Groulx, Poehling, Benson, Beaucage, Lind, Sprong,Stankoven, Ahcan, PO. Joseph, McIsaac Goalies: Wallstedt, UPL, Comrie, Ersson, S.Skinner, Skarek, Johansson
I have 3 of them (Staal, Edler, Benn) on my team.
For this season think its equivalent. Benn>Staal and Edler > Green.
Think Benn and Staal are similar for future, while Edler is safer keeper but Green higher upside/risk
Semi-retired
Can anyone else spare a minute for their input. I hand out Reps for your time. Thanks.
14 Team Dynasty League - 23 man roster, 25 man minors w/ custom cap, salaries & contracts
Skaters: (Start: 4C, 4LW, 4RW, 6D) - G/A/Pt/(+/-)/PIM/SOG/STP/TOI
Goalies: (Start 2) - W/GAA/SV/SV%
C: Schiefele, Zacha, RyJo, Patrick
LW: Guentzel, J.Robertson, Domi, Kempe
RW: Puljujarvi, Gurianov, D.Strome, Duchene
D: Ekblad, E.Karlsson, OEL, Morrissey, Jokiharju, Bear, Weber (LTIR)
G: MAF, Price, Driedger, Bishop (LTIR)
Minors: (25 max)
Skaters: Hayton, JAD, J.Boqvist, Dahlen, Bunting, Gusev, Damiani, Groulx, Poehling, Benson, Beaucage, Lind, Sprong,Stankoven, Ahcan, PO. Joseph, McIsaac Goalies: Wallstedt, UPL, Comrie, Ersson, S.Skinner, Skarek, Johansson
I would take the Benn side. Green is looking to come back soon and Benn is just simply better than Staal in all cats with a better support cast. Staal is just simply in a terrible situation right now. If you are looking for longterm then it would still be the Benn side cuz he is still a developing star and with Green that's just win right there. Staal will bounce back tho as he is a proven 60+ point consistent scorer. I still choose Benn
One year league:
G 1 A 1 +/- 0.5 PIM 0.5 PPP 1 SHP 2 ||W 5 L -2 GA -.25 SHO 5
C Marleau(C, LW) / J. Staal(C, LW)
LW Hall / Eriksson(LW, RW)
RW Selanne / Malkin(C, RW)
D Giordano / D. Boyle / Enstrom / Timonen
Util Ott(C, LW)
G Fleury / Ward
BN Varlamov / Hiller / Downie(LW, RW) / Purcell
IR
Funny, I just saw another thread with E. Staal and Edler for Benn and Streit.
I think it boils down to Green. If you think Green is going to light things up once he's back I like that side better. If you are looking for more consistency then I would take the Staal / Edler side.
High risk, high reward type move, but I'd probably roll the dice and go for it since Green could be a difference maker if he can play like he did previously.
16 Team 4th Year H2H Yahoo! Keeper League, 2012 Champion
Keep 8 (Max 1 Goalie) + 2* (23 and under)
G,A,+/-,PIM,PPP,SOG,FW,HIT,BLK,W,GAA,SV,SV%
2LW,3C,2RW,3D,1U,2G,8BN,3IR
LW Landeskog*, C Tavares*,Getzlaf, RW Ovechkin,Malkin(C),Seguin*(C),D Subban,G Lundqvist, Lehner*
Draft - 1st,2 2nds, 2 3rds.
Originally Posted by You Know
Funny, I just saw another thread with E. Staal and Edler for Benn and Streit
haha, yeah I wasn't getting much feedback from this so I posted the counter offer the other GM made me in the other post.
I also like this deal better, but I'm a little hesitant with the risks associated with Green. I'll try and re-offer this again.
Cheers!
14 Team Dynasty League - 23 man roster, 25 man minors w/ custom cap, salaries & contracts
Skaters: (Start: 4C, 4LW, 4RW, 6D) - G/A/Pt/(+/-)/PIM/SOG/STP/TOI
Goalies: (Start 2) - W/GAA/SV/SV%
C: Schiefele, Zacha, RyJo, Patrick
LW: Guentzel, J.Robertson, Domi, Kempe
RW: Puljujarvi, Gurianov, D.Strome, Duchene
D: Ekblad, E.Karlsson, OEL, Morrissey, Jokiharju, Bear, Weber (LTIR)
G: MAF, Price, Driedger, Bishop (LTIR)
Minors: (25 max)
Skaters: Hayton, JAD, J.Boqvist, Dahlen, Bunting, Gusev, Damiani, Groulx, Poehling, Benson, Beaucage, Lind, Sprong,Stankoven, Ahcan, PO. Joseph, McIsaac Goalies: Wallstedt, UPL, Comrie, Ersson, S.Skinner, Skarek, Johansson
I like the Benn/E Staal side here but it's bit riskier - Staal is more proven than Benn and Green has ridiculous talent but his injuries are getting ridiculous.
However, I'd do it without too much hesitation.
I would keep Edler over Green, less risk and he is in a great situation.
I really like Benn but you are really trading Edler and Staal for Benn as Green value is so low right and you can really only count on him for half a season if your lucky.
Staal had a great night last night and may well be rounding the corner here.
IDHL League 28 team H2H league multicat full keeper
Rebuilding
Cooley, Guenther, Hoglander, Lundell, Quinn, Voronkov, Stankoven, Carlsson
Hutson, Zellweger, Clarke, KA Miller, Xhekai, Malinski, Thrun
Dostal, Hofer
Beck, Bolduc, Dumais, Gaucher, Gunler, Pervalov
Ufko, Benning, Del Mastro, Peart, Grudinin
Zherenko
I'm going to go against the grain here..
I like Staal and Edler over Benn and Green, although I think this is a pretty even trade. Depends what stats you are wanting.
I don't agree with Benn > Staal
I think they're even in your scoring format. Staal is still among the league leaders in SOG.. Yeah his +/- sucks, but I think in time, that it will go down (or up, whichever way you're thinking about it.. It will get 'more positive' is what I'm trying to say)
I also think Edler = Green. Edler is still improving, and with HITS in your league, Edler is a beast for that, plus he's on the top PP unit with the Sedins and Kesler, plays the most minutes of the Canucks D or is among them night in and night out.
Green is good... we think. He had the one great year and another good year, but has barely played the last 2 years.
Posting Permissions