Skinner for Nugent-Hopkins?????

[Prime_Time]

Should I trade Skinner for RNH???

I can put RNH in my farm team until he reach 30 games in the NHL.

Please help?

Look at my signature for details.

[Lemmy]

I would do it then put him on your farm Skinner is a borderline keeper for you anyway.

Keepers (keep 10)


Forwards
Ovechkin, Heatley, Perry, Stamkos, Getzlaf, M. Richards

Defensemen
Visnovsky, J. Carlson

Goalies
Lundqvist, Bryzgalov

[Prime_Time]

Thanks. Someone else?

[Instant Karma]

I don't know, I'd be keeping Skinner over Heater or Visz, myself. I see Heatley as still being valuable, but on the downside. Someone I'd be looking to move soon.

I'd offer Heater instead of Skinner.

[Instant Karma]

That being said, I'd probably do neither for RNH.

If you have too many keepers, I'd be looking to package two for an upgrade.

[kenzle1r]

I don't know, I'd be keeping Skinner over Heater or Visz, myself. I see Heatley as still being valuable, but on the downside. Someone I'd be looking to move soon.

I'd offer Heater instead of Skinner.

I agree that I'd keep Skinner over Heater or Vis...but I think it's lacking the "big picture" in this deal. If you keep Skinner over one of those two, you lose out on RNH. So the question becomes, do you prefer Skinner as a keeper over one of those two AND having RNH on your team. The answer is a resounding no IMO.

So to me, I take the deal and run...I like the keepers suggested above and you have RNH on your prospects team for the first 30 games of his career. A huge bonus.

On a side note, I make that deal regardless of keeper value and prospect status as I feel RNH is going to have the better career. Having the ability to keep another NHLer like Heater (or Vis - whoever you consider your worst keeper) by being able to put RNH on your prospects team is a huge bonus.

Also, it's been suggested to move Heater instead of Skinner. If you can do that...great...but I'd be happy with the original offer and wouldn't want to ruin a good opportunity to acquire RNH.

Good luck!