Kulemin vs. Hartnell

[WingNutUpNorth]

who would you rather have in a Dynasty league? Kuly is 4 years younger,but Hartnell fills more cats.Lets hear your opinions.Thanks

[JHM]

Your extendeds don't give a significant enhancement to one player or the other. A 50 point Hartnell, is about equivalent to a 60 point Kulemin. Kulemin did a bit better on the PP last year and also had a SH point. That all sort of offset Hartnell's 140PM.

So, it comes down to which risk you prefer.

Does Hartnell rise 10 points due to the departure of Carter/Richards?
Does Hartnell stay the same?
Does Kulemin slump or take the step to the next level? For the moment, I'd like to see him repeat his 57 points.

I think I'd take Hartnell and the safety he represents. 55 points, quality PM, and a few extra teams points.

[dmvincent]

Give me Kulemin, he gets better year after year. Hartnell is pretty much the same every year, but I'll take the upside play here in Kulemin.

[Filadelphia]

Hartnell is an easy choice for me. I see him getting at least 50 points this season.

[WildCard2180]

Kulemin every time.