Dubnyk or Rinne? ROS

[Right handed shot]

Wins, GAA and Sv Pct. for ROS. Who would you rather have?

[Eskimo Brother]

Rinne. Not much faith in either goalie at the moment for good reason, but I believe in Nashville much more than Minny as a team right now (Though I may be slightly biased).

[gooding74]

I might go Dubnyk ROS simply because he has been less erratic, considering that two of your three categories are ratios.

[FinnishFlash]

Dubnyk for me.

Dub has actually been playing quite well most of the season, the team just cant get it together.

[Right handed shot]

Anyone else?

[M_Vandenbrand]

Dubnyk. Rinne is so sporadic it's not even funny. Deal him if you can on name value alone. See if you can steal Mrazek or someone like that. Might be aiming high but you should try.

[blayze]

Both have been huge disappointments this year... between the two I'd have to go with Rinne. I think it's more likely the Preds finish strong.

[CHunter]

Close but Rinne gets my vote

[Front89]

Dubnyk for me, beats Rinne is GAA and SV% handily and is close on W (2 less).

How has Dubnyk been a huge disappointment? Are you thinking in comparison to the incredible stretch run last season? That is just unrealistic especially since the team is not playing as well either.

Dubnyk has 2.37, .918, 4 SO and 18 W. Remember also he has been playing with a knee issue for months - the all-star break would have been nice for him, but it was his first all-star berth and I totally understand why he would not turn it down.

I think MN will make one more big push this season and I expect Dubnyk's numbers will be better by season's end.

[lucafen4]

Rinne - 12 GA in last 6 games - including 6 vs. Philly

Dub has given up 5, 3, 4 in last three games and has posted .833, .897, 833 GAA in those starts,

Gotta take the hot hand & go Rinne

[Demeech]

Dubnyk. Look at how many losses dubnyk has while allowing 2 or less goals. Its insane. Rinnes kind of fallen off.

[kevinsrangers]

Duby for me.