This trade has me thinking....

[PC_269_]

Today I was offered:

Corey Schneider
Martin St. Louis

I would give:
Dwayne Roloson
Luke Adam
Scott Hartnell

League settings:
12 Teams, H2H, ONE YEAR
22 players, 17 starters, 5 bench positions and 2 IR spots. No games played limits. 60 MAXIMUM moves for the entire year.

3 Centers
3 Left Wingers
3 Right Wingers
5 Defensemen
1 Utility
2 Goalies
5 Bench Players
2 Injured Reserves

Scoring Categories:
Skating: G, A, PTS, +/-, PIMs, PPPs
Goalies: Wins, Saves, SO's, GAA, SV%

Clearly, goalies mean a lot in this league:

My team:
Centers: Evgeni Malkin, Mike Ribeiro, Nik Antropov, Luke Adam, Steve Ott
Left Wingers: Dany Heatley, James Neal, Scott Hartnell, Tuomo Ruutu
Right Wingers: Steve Downie, Marian Gaborik, Kyle Okposo
Defensemen: P.K Subban, Jack Johnson, Ryan Suter, Joni Pitkanen, Kurtis Foster
Goalies: Carey Price, Jaroslav Halak, Dwayne Roloson, Michal Neuvirth
IR: Nino Neidereider, Ales Hemsky

So, then again the trade is the following:

Corey Schneider
Martin St. Louis

I would give:
Dwayne Roloson
Luke Adam
Scott Hartnell

Im just not sure if it would be worth it or not, considering that Hartnell and Roloson are excellent buy lows and goal tending is huge in this league....does this trade help me enough THIS YEAR?

I would welcome the opinions of the the faithful on this clearly difficult subject matter.

[notoriusbug]

I would do this. St Louis is by far the best player in this deal, plus Schneider is going to get his fair of starts in Vcr (he's starting for the 3rd time tonight)...

Roloson is 40+ and the team has already said they are going to rest him often throughout the year to keep him as fresh as possible of for the playoffs...I would guess Roloson gets 52 starts and Garon gets 30...

I would do this deal ASAP.

[fakeblood]

Definitely do this deal. You're losing an unproven rookie (who was most likely a free agent signing anyway), a declining netminder, and a third-liner getting snubbed on the PP for a top 10 forward and a goalie who will be seated nicely on your roster succeeding your starters.

[mister_mcgoo]

yeah i'd do that in a heartbeat