Question for the ages!

[NYR9394]

Next year ONLY. Categories are Wins, GAA, SV% and Shutouts. (I decided to include a poll for those with A.D.D and those who really like graphs)


Who do you take?: Luongo or Brodeur

[BlackGold]

I'm a big fan of strong teams, and I'm liking Vancouver vs Edm (early in the season), Calg and Min (weak offense), with Colorado possibly being the only real threat.

Brodeur is very proven but the Pens and Philly look too dangerous for me. Islanders could surprise like Edm, leaving only NYR as the possible weak offsense for Brodeur to face.

[Zorro]

I have a really good feeling about Luongo this coming year. With the d-men they have added (Hamhuis and Ballard), they are looking really strong on the back-end..

I hate going against Broduer(arguably the best goalie ever) but this coming season, I am taking LOU..

[angus]

Tough call. Both teams are strong on defense. Vancouver is in a significantly weaker division, but Brodeur had a better 2009-10.

Flip a coin? I'd pick Luongo just because of how weak the NW is.

[Chicleteur]

Tough call. Both teams are strong on defense. Vancouver is in a significantly weaker division, but Brodeur had a better 2009-10.

Flip a coin? I'd pick Luongo just because of how weak the NW is.

Yeah, I'd be tempted to take Luongo as well for that reason alone. Otherwise, I think their numbers could be really close.

[metaldude26]

Every year I figure it's the year the torch is passed but then Brodeur goes and bests Luongo again. I'm changing my tune this year. Brodeur continues his dominance of the goalie position next season so he's the one I'd take first.

[Knuckles14]

depending on how your league works.....I think Louie will be playing a few less games than usual this coming season. Gillis has as much as said so........telling us in a press conference a while back that he expects Schneider to get in to 20-25 games.

On the flip side, as much as MB has played his fair share of 70-70 game seasons, that can't go on forever either.

[TML]

Don't get me wrong, I love Luongo for saving our butts in the Olympics, but you've got to go with Brodeur. He's been better than Luongo every year, so I'm expecting the same thing.

Luongo has never been super awesome anyways. I don't care whether
he's had a bad defense, Brodeur's had bad defenses before. Luongo still needs to play better if he wants to beat Brodeur. It's not the defense's fault, it's his.

[Shake]

I take Martin Broduer in one year league. I think Vanny is imporved and I think Bobby Lu does just fine, but I gotta go with history and Broduer has been " money" year in and year out, no reason to think otherwise just yet, keeper league take Luongo of course, but I think Broduer still reigns as dominate for this coming year. Broduer has carried my teams time and time again, and I to am faced with similar situation , and without even blinking an eye I tab Broduer as my starting goalie. If it fails me, well at least I made the decision of taking the best goalie of the 2 - which is Broduer - live or die with he best goalie...Broduer is your answer!

[Doctor Robz]

Everyone is talking about Vancouver back-end and how weak NW is , but what about NJD Ds ?

With Volchenkov and Talinder up in the depth charts , watch out ... did I say shutouts?

[Sleemans]

Since it's for regular season only, I would give the edge to Lunogo. I like what Vancouver has done with their D this off season, and he should benefit from the upgrades.

[fulcrum]

I've bet against Brodeur too many times and been burnt. He's the guy I pick every year until he retires.