Who Would You Pick to Keep for 1 year

[Randallizer]

I have one spot open on my roster. We are using a Roto stlye format and renew each year. The scoring categories are G,A,total pts, +/-, SOG and Pims.
The choice is either Erat or Hudler.
Who would be your choice?

Thanks in advance for your comments.

[Shoeless]

Erat is going to get prime ice time especially with Sully out and Kariya gone likely more PP time which translates into points. 60 to 70 points seems realistic.

Hudler will get more ice time with the changes in Detroit but not with the big guns so I think optimistically a top end of 45 for this year which is a big step up. He is a shooter so he might in fact contribute more in the cat than Erat - but likely not enough to swing the decision his way. He will have a very decent +/- but Erat\'s won\'t be bad. No great differentiation on PIM\'s I suspect.

This would be an easy call for me of Erat. Top line, 4th year and improving.

[smoothfun]

i agree , erat , he\'s consistent and a bit underated.

[The Comish]

Agree with the two previous posts, Erat is the way to go on this one. He\'s more a sure thing than Hudler. Sure Hudler has more upside, but will he show it this year? Not sure, go with Erat.