Can't really help you but I'm asking myself something similar. Got offered Stamkos für Stützle, but I still hope that Stützle will bounce back.
Tbh I'm very close to trade away Stützle, when I see the way Ottawa plays atm. At least he used his Body last Season. This year he even forgets about hitting.
Wait. Why do you need to choose? Are you trying to trade one? Or trade for one? Or is the league sooo shallow that you will pick one from the waiver wire?