Holtby or Talbot?

[Henrik18]

If you have to trade 1 of them,who would you keep and who would you trade in my league?

Holtby is younger,but probably is in trouble to lose the starting job?

Talbot is older but the starter in Minny!?

What about the next years?
Holtby probably in Seattle?
If not probably backup to Demko next season?

Have 2 offers on the table...exactly the same

It‘s either Holtby or Talbot for a 2nd round pick( 11-15 range probably)!
Which one should i accept?

[agentzero]

What does the pick net you in terms of a player? I would probably trade away Holtby as I think Vancouver will be in tougher than they think in the North Division, but it depends on what you can get.

[Henrik18]

It‘s basically a prospectdraft...we have just 3 rounds of drafting... we have to drop 3 players every year!
So this pick will get me probably an older nhl player like Radulov or something...or a prosoect from next years draftclass!

The thing is,i‘m not just looking on the upcoming season...i‘m fine with my goalies this year...i know this year probably Talbot is the better choice...but what about thr next 3-5 years?
Is Holtby completly done,or is ther hope he can put it all together?

[kovalchuk17]

Id move Holtby if moving one as I believe Demko will get the majority of starts as soon as this season. Holtby will get exposed in the expansion draft 100% but may not necessarily get picked up by Seattle.

Talbot has a pretty decent defense in front of him in a weak division.