Nash and Tanguay for Marleau and E. Stall

[destructivedevil97]

i would be giving up marleau and stalll


do i win this trade or do i lose....and by how much

thanks guys

appreciate it

[Anonymous]

I think I would take this, wingers are much more valuable, and I would say that now is a great buy low time on Nash, he gets all kinds of opporotunities and Hitchcock said he could have had 20 goals by now. You are selling Staal at a low point, but I\'d say you are getting close to full value for him here. Its not a landslide win, but I think you come out on top. Staal will pick it up.

[playmaker26]

I think you lose the trade to be honest. Staal is slumping but he is still the best player in this deal and I\'d rather have Marleau over Tanguay.

[Lu Kai]

I disagree. I\'d much rather have Marleau and Staal. It\'s true that scoring wingers are harder to find that productive C, but with with 4 Utility slots, you shouldn\'t have any trouble getting your best guys in the line up. Marleau looks like he\'ll put up around a ppg, and Staal should beter that by year\'s end. You won\'t get that kind of production out of Nash + Tanguay.