Keller or Mantha for..........

[renello]

Team looking for LW. He has some interest in Keller or Mantha. He has Duchene, Simmonds, dadonov, stone and radulov.

I think simmonds or stone would be an upgrade for either. Keller and Mantha could become keepers for me but stone and simmonds would definately be keepers. Duchene a bit of a risk but big upside if traded and he offers a lot of multi cat goodness. Not sure I would trade for dadonov or radulov.

Your thoughts.

[Bass56]

If you can get Simmonds for Mantha, I’d be all over that!

[MZac]

Second Mantha for Simmonds.. I'd keep Keller for now.

[stimperi]

Sell high for Mantha. Simmonds would be a great haul. Keller is a keeper.

[Axeman33]

If you can get Simmonds for Mantha, I’d be all over that!

I concur.

[lucafen4]

sounds great... I highly doubt a GM with any knowledge sells Simmonds for Mantha straight up. You'll need to add something. DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT trade Keller. #badmove!! There's not a winger there worth Keller. you will regret trading keller as long as you remain in this pool. if you take one piece of advice let it be this.

[GSD]

Sell high for Mantha. Simmonds would be a great haul. Keller is a keeper.

I agree with this. PS I love your posts, if for no other reason, your pic��

[Wonko]

I would likely trade Mantha for any of Stone, Duchene or Dadonov. Radulov was moved off the Sequin/Benn line last night in favour of Ritchie and that line proceeded to dominated the game. Radulov may have lost his sweet gig. Approach him with caution until we see how things settle out.

Not likely getting Simmonds for Mantha unless other owner is a noob.

I think I prefer Stone as the safest of the three, followed by Duchene who has added value in your league with face off from the wing (most risk however) and then Dadonov.

[renello]

I would likely trade Mantha for any of Stone, Duchene or Dadonov. Radulov was moved off the Sequin/Benn line last night in favour of Ritchie and that line proceeded to dominated the game. Radulov may have lost his sweet gig. Approach him with caution until we see how things settle out.

Not likely getting Simmonds for Mantha unless other owner is a noob.

I think I prefer Stone as the safest of the three, followed by Duchene who has added value in your league with face off from the wing (most risk however) and then Dadonov.

Great advice.

[Sulla]

I’d take Simmonds over Keller as well tbh....

[lucafen4]

I’d take Simmonds over Keller as well tbh....

Simmonds loses a lot of his peripheral value in this points based set up. 2pts for a G, 1 for an A & .1 for hits & shots. Keller could outpoint Simmonds THIS year. and his shot totals are elite already. At best Simmonds is a wash.. moving forward Keller pulls ahead.

I would not trade Keller in this set up

[Wonko]

Simmonds loses a lot of his peripheral value in this points based set up. 2pts for a G, 1 for an A & .1 for hits & shots. Keller could outpoint Simmonds THIS year. and his shot totals are elite already. At best Simmonds is a wash.. moving forward Keller pulls ahead.

I politely agree to disagree Lucafen4. Simmonds finished 8th overall of all RW's in this league last year and 7th the year before.

Keller would need close to 80 points to out point Simmonds in this league (the season Gaudreau got 78 points he still finished 8 places behind Simmonds).