Trade 1) Depends on your RB depth at the position.
Trade 2) Depends on how many keepers and if PPR or not.
I have Mackinnon is 2 of my leagues...
Im getting an offer of Jimmy Graham for Mackinnon in one. I have Barnidge is my TE slot right now... Charles/Bell in my RB slot. Worth doing?
In another league I'm getting an offer of Gio Bernard and a 3rd rd pick for Mackinnon . . . Im already 0-4 in that league and looking so sell some pieces. Doesn't seem too bad to me.
10 Team H2H Baseball- Cats
R, HR, RBI, BB, SB, AVG, XBH
W, ERA, SV, K WHIP, QS
C: D. Jansen
1B: P. Goldschmidt
2B: J. Villar
3B: E. Suarez
SS: J. Peraza
OF: M. Trout
OF: G. Stanton
OF: A. Benintendi
UTIL: G. Springer
UTIL: J. Gallo
P: T. Bauer
P: Z. Wheeler
RP: T. Glasnow
RP: K. Maeda
P: G. Marquez
P: L. Castillo
P: S. Bieber
P: C. McHugh
Bench: J. Profar, T. White, M. Smith, C. Martinez (SP), G. Holland
Trade 1) Depends on your RB depth at the position.
Trade 2) Depends on how many keepers and if PPR or not.
If you are rebuilding I like the Gio and a 3rd round pick for MKinnon!
Graham is a nice add... but not at the risk of losing depth at RB. Unless you can add Barnidge and get a lower RB back in the deal.
My RB Depth is Bell, Charles, Blount, Ware, Williams
and I am trying to rebuild in the other league. We only get four keepers. Right now, mine are Eli, Cooper. Allen, Ingram.. not too special
10 Team H2H Baseball- Cats
R, HR, RBI, BB, SB, AVG, XBH
W, ERA, SV, K WHIP, QS
C: D. Jansen
1B: P. Goldschmidt
2B: J. Villar
3B: E. Suarez
SS: J. Peraza
OF: M. Trout
OF: G. Stanton
OF: A. Benintendi
UTIL: G. Springer
UTIL: J. Gallo
P: T. Bauer
P: Z. Wheeler
RP: T. Glasnow
RP: K. Maeda
P: G. Marquez
P: L. Castillo
P: S. Bieber
P: C. McHugh
Bench: J. Profar, T. White, M. Smith, C. Martinez (SP), G. Holland
League 1 - I'd do that deal right now.
League 2 - I only asked because a 3rd rounder is big difference if there are only a few keepers or a lot of keepers. McKinnon (assuming AP plays next year, surprised if he doesn't) and Bernard both have zero keeper appeal so really this is about the pick. I like Gio better in a PPR anyways so I pull the trigger here.
In summary, I do both deals.