1 yr league Trade- Malkin and Duchene for Vorachek and Henrik Sedin

[TMLfan]

The trade is

Malkin and Duchene
for
Voracek and Henrik Sedin

The points system for my league is 3 points for goals and 2 points for assists

Who would you take?

[snipshow101]

Malkin AINEC

[rangerfan2430]

I'd take the Malkin side. I think he is going to have a beast year

[skiteam14]

Take the Malkin side.

Back of the napkin estimates:

Malkin: 30(3pts/g) + 45(2pts/a) = 180 pts
Duchene: 25(3pts/g) + 30(3pts/a) = 165 pts

Voracek: 20(3pts/g) + 50(2pts/a) = 160 pts
Henrik: 15(3pts/g) + 45(2pts/a) = 135 pts

Malkin + Duchene (345 pts) > Voracek + H. Sedin (295 pts)

And that's with a conservative estimate for Duchene.