do I make this deal

[JimmyCanuck]

Pass, Keep what you have!

[The Black Panther]

I don't see what the scoring is for goalies but in my experience with points-based scoring, there is less value in an efficient starter like Elliott who wins a lot but plays a smaller percentage of games. I'd wager the gap between him and Bernier isn't very large but I could be wrong. Like others have said, you can probably do better with those assets. Selling low right now.

Wow cant believe I missed that. Not to mention space on sig was tight. Had to be innovative to get it all in. Updated.
Just to give u an idea of an avg win, yesterday Rinne got 7.2pts and Reimer 7.47.
BElliott
This yr 26gp= 151.34FP 5.82FP/G
Last year 31gp= 172.36 5.56FP/G
JBernier
This year 37gp = 159.5FP 4.31FP/G
Last year 37gp = 240.83FP 4.38FP/G

Bernier definitely trending downwards(Leafs not good for a while) but better upside.
Elliott less games on a waaay better team but yes need to factor in Allen.
I am close to first(2nd place). Is this a huge risk?

[Fatman]

No, none of those deals appeal to me

[The Black Panther]

No, none of those deals appeal to me

Even Bernier for Elliott straightup?

[Bomm Bastic]

Even Bernier for Elliott straightup?

I like that.

[metaldude26]

I can see doing Elliott for Bernier straight up, if only because you'll save some money the next couple of years. Not a talent upgrade though. This scoring isn't exactly Elliott's friend.

[The Black Panther]

You dont thk he'll outproduce Bernier until atleast 2016-17?

[metaldude26]

You dont thk he'll outproduce Bernier until atleast 2016-17?

We looking at the same numbers? I don't see any scoring edge for Elliott.

[The Black Panther]

BElliottThis yr 26gp= 151.34FP 5.82FP/G
Last year 31gp= 172.36 5.56FP/G
JBernier
This year 37gp = 159.5FP 4.31FP/G
Last year 37gp = 240.83FP 4.38FP/G

[metaldude26]

BElliottThis yr 26gp= 151.34FP 5.82FP/G
Last year 31gp= 172.36 5.56FP/G
JBernier
This year 37gp = 159.5FP 4.31FP/G
Last year 37gp = 240.83FP 4.38FP/G

And the per-game numbers don't mean much if he's starting less.

Like I said, I'd do Bernier for Elliott to save the money. Helps that you've got Rinne and Andersen starting more so you don't necessarily need the volume from your third goalie. I just don't see Elliott being that much better in a vacuum because of the points-based scoring.

[Jordyr77]

I think you should do the JVR deal